A/HRC/27/35
World Trends in Freedom of Expression and Media Development, in which it is found that
nearly 50 per cent of States failed to even respond to requests by the UNESCO DirectorGeneral for voluntary information on the status of judicial inquiries into journalist killings,
and called upon States to be more transparent, to share information and to take concrete
steps to address impunity. These could consist in appointing special prosecutors and
improving the overall functioning of the judicial system.
14.
The Deputy Director-General of UNESCO, Getachew Engida, confirmed that
impunity was unfortunately “the name of the game”, and that statistics clearly showed that
many States had not taken the necessary steps to investigate the killings of journalists. He
called the situation unacceptable, since the killing of a journalist amounted to taking
oxygen out of the democratic system. He, like Mr. Smyth, regretted the fact that many
States did not cooperate with UNESCO in the collection of information regarding judicial
inquiries into the killings of journalists, but assured that the organization continued to work
with States to persuade them to be more transparent. Although UNESCO, together with
OHCHR and other United Nations agencies, had spearheaded the United Nations Plan of
Action on the Safety of Journalists and the Issue of Impunity, it was clear that, without real
political commitment from States, the Plan of Action risked remaining on paper only and
not translating into tangible results. While noting that there was an international legal
framework for the protection of journalists in place, adjustments in the legal system at the
national level were needed in many countries. Mr. Engida referred to the silencing of
journalists through anti-terrorism or national security laws. He also stressed the need to
build capacity of law enforcement officials and the judiciary with respect to the protection
of journalists, as well as of journalists to better protect themselves. Looking towards the
future, Mr. Engida highlighted that UNESCO was advocating for the post-2015
development agenda to include freedom of expression, the rule of law and good governance
as stand-alone goals.
15.
The OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media, Dunja Mijatović, described
attacks on journalists and the media, and on freedom of expression in general, as
unacceptable. She identified lack of political will as an important issue, and stated that
States should be asked why they do not comply with the norms to which they have
voluntarily agreed. The international community needed to find a way to engage with such
States, to discover how to open doors where they remain closed. Ms. Mijatović also
highlighted the importance of continuing to repeat the names of journalists who had been
killed, and to avoid referring to them as numbers only. In this context, she remembered
Anna Politkovskaya, Elmar Huseynov, Hrant Dink, Milan Pantić, Dada Vujasinović,
Slavko Ćuruvija and Duško Jovanović. Ms. Mijatović suggested that other important
questions were why journalism was so fiercely attacked, why the truth was being stopped,
and why the work of journalists was often regarded as inconvenient. She called upon the
international community to condemn with a stronger voice those countries that did not live
up to standards, to be bold and courageous and not to be afraid of naming and shaming,
because too much diplomacy in the case of murder was unhelpful.
16.
According to Abeer Saady, a journalist and Vice-President of the Syndicate of
Journalists of Egypt, although defining journalism had become difficult, it was about
informing people and allowing them to make enlightened decisions. Ms. Saady referred to
statistics gathered by the Committee to Protect Journalists, which suggested that 49 out of
the 70 journalists killed in 2013 (and for which the motive was confirmed) were from her
region. She advocated for a long-term perspective, and emphasized that an investment in
the safety of journalists in the region should not be regarded as an investment in those
individuals or even in the profession, but rather as an investment in democratic
transformation. She stated that 90 per cent of journalists killed in the region were either
shot in the head or tortured before death, and that using a badge to distinguish oneself as a
journalist was no longer considered a means of providing protection but rather of increasing
6
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents