A/HRC/12/48
page 101
representatives of foreign Governments and international delegations, and rescue operations. An
obituary of one of the policemen killed, published on the website of al-Qassam Brigades, claims
that he was attending “a military refreshing course.”255
400. The police gave the Mission small cube-shaped (4x4x4 mm3 and 2x4x4 mm3) metal
fragments allegedly from the missiles fired at this location. Information provided by NGOs that
visited the site soon after the strike and collected samples of the munitions fragments confirm
that they were found there. Laboratory analysis of the cubes establishes that they are made of
tungsten.256
401. In a second location at Arafat City police headquarters, two projectiles fired by Israeli
fighter jets left two craters. No one was present in the area at the time of the strike. The third
location visited by the Mission was near the north gate of the police headquarters where a
projectile, most likely a missile, killed police chief Tawfiq Jabr. Reports indicate that other sites
at the police headquarters, not visited by the Mission, were also targeted.
402. A second police training course targeted was reportedly attended by around 50 policemen.
Twenty-eight of them were killed in the strike. According to the police spokesperson, the
training course was designed to instruct police officers on how to deal with police officers who
abused their power as well as on cultural and economic issues relevant to police work.257
Moreover, as the survivors were trying to flee through the western gate of the police city, they
were reportedly targeted by two anti-personnel missiles, which caused deaths and injuries. While
the Mission did not receive official information from the Gaza authorities on the number of
policemen killed at the police headquarters on 27 December 2008, a report by an NGO submitted
to the Mission states that 89 policemen died as a result of this attack.
403. Abbas police station in central Gaza City was, according to the station commander, hit by
three missiles on 27 December 2008 at 11.35 a.m.258 Officials at the police station had just been
informed of the attack on Arafat City police a few minutes earlier and immediate evacuation of
the station had begun. Nine policemen were killed, 20 more reportedly injured. There were,
according to the station commander, five detainees (common criminal suspects) in the police
cells, who were released before the attack. There were members of the public going about their
normal business at the police station at the time of the strike, including women and children.
TAWTHEQ estimates the material damage caused by the attack at US$ 80,000.
255
See http://www.alqassam.ps/arabic/sohdaa5.php?id=1342.
Laboratory analysis was carried out under the supervision of Lt. Col. Lane of Ireland’s Defence Forces, an expert
witness of the Mission. In his report to the Mission he notes that “the IDF have deployed newly developed highprecision low-collateral damage missile systems…. In mid-2004 Rafael noted that a new warhead for the Spike had
been developed for operations in urban areas.” See also Human Rights Watch, Precisely Wrong: Gaza Civilians
Killed by Israeli Drone-Launched Missiles (June 2009), where it is stated that the fragments are likely to have been
from drone-launched “Spike” missiles produced by the Israeli firm Rafael Advanced Defense Systems (pp. 6-7, 11-12).
256
257
Mission phone interview with Mr. Shahwan, Gaza Police Spokesperson, 12 July 2009.
258
Interview with station commander, Maj. Iyad Jabr el Horani, 9 June 2009.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents