A/HRC/12/48
page 142
1.
The facts
599. When the Israeli air offensive began on 27 December a government building opposite the
al-Quds administrative building on al-Abraj Street was almost totally destroyed. The building
had previously served as a criminal detention centre and is still referred to locally by that
designation although it had recently been used for other purposes, including customs
administration. The same building was reportedly struck on a number of other occasions after
27 December. When the Mission visited in June 2009, the site was completely demolished.
600. Diagonally opposite al-Quds Hospital on Jami’at ad-Duwal al-Arabiyah Street was
another building rented to the Government and used primarily for public registry functions.
Today only the ground floor of the building remains. Witnesses indicate that the upper floors had
been destroyed, probably by artillery fire, around 6 and 7 January.
601. Three senior doctors at the hospital and two residents from al-Abraj Street indicated that
at some point between 3 and 6 January several tanks were stationed several hundred metres east
of al-Quds hospital, visible from the ambulance depot. Throughout the days of 5, 6, 7 and
8 January there was significant artillery fire on a number of civilian apartment buildings on
al-Abraj Street. On 8 January 2009 the seventh-floor apartment of Dr. Jaber Abu al-Naja was
struck. His wife and son-in-law were killed immediately as they sat on the balcony of the
apartment eating pastries. His wife was cut in half by the explosion and his son-in-law was
thrown from the balcony on to the street below. His daughter, Ihsan, was seriously injured and
taken to al-Quds hospital for treatment. Dr. Jaber Abu al-Naja is the former Ambassador of the
PLO to Senegal and a well-known Fatah politician.373
602. By 15 January the area immediately to the south of al-Quds hospital (the customs building
and the registry building) had been totally or very substantially destroyed. The area to the east on
al-Abraj Street had been significantly attacked by artillery fire.
603. By this time a large number of civilians (several hundreds) had also gathered in the
hospital buildings seeking safety.
604. During the night of 14 January Israeli armed forces began an extended barrage of artillery
fire over the area. It continued into the morning of 15 January. Between 8 and 9 a.m. doctors in
the main building were in the principal meeting room when shells landed on either side of the
building. They saw white phosphorous wedges burning near a container of diesel and efforts
were successfully made to move those away. The initial explosions had blown out the office
windows. At about the same time it became apparent that the administrative building on the
corner had also been hit. The hospital building next to it has a large timber-built component. The
risk of fire spreading was immense and a witness described how hospital staff, including senior
doctors, all sought to break, by hand, the wooden bridge way that linked the administrative
building to the hospital building to prevent the fire from spreading.
605. Shortly after the initial explosions and fire were observed, a tank shell directly penetrated
the rear of the middle hospital building. That part of the building is made of corrugated iron and
373
Interview with Dr. Jaber Abu al-Naja, 4 July 2009.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents