A/HRC/12/48
page 197
904. Flechettes were fired during the military operations on several occasions by tanks and on
at least one occasion from an air-to-surface missile of the “Helfire” type.486 In all cases those hit
by these devices were civilians and in one case were attending a condolence tent following the
loss of a family member who was also killed by flechettes.
905. Flechettes are known to bend, break or “tumble” on impact with human flesh. Such
performances are often part of the flechettes design characteristic and are marketed as such.
“Tumbling” in particular is adjudged to be a further determination of the projectiles
“incapacitation” effect.487 The Mission notes, however, that flechettes can be designed to be free
of these post-impact characteristics if it is desired that they should do so.
C.
Alleged use of munitions causing a specific type of injury
906. The Mission received reports from Palestinian and foreign doctors who operated in Gaza
during the military operations of a strikingly high percentage of patients with severed legs as a
result of the impact of projectiles launched by the Israeli armed forces. Dr. Mads Gilbert, a
Norwegian anaesthetist, and Dr. Eric Fosse, a Norwegian surgeon, who carried out surgery in
al-Shifa Hospital from 31 December 2008 to 10 January 2009,488 described to the Mission the
characteristics of the wounds. The amputations mostly occurred at waist height in children,
generally lower in adults, and were combined with skin-deep, third-degree burns, four to six
fingers upward from the amputation. Where the amputation took place, the flesh was cauterized
as a result of the heat. The patients with these amputations had no shrapnel wounds, but red
flashes on the abdomen and chest. The excision of large pieces of flesh was not infrequent in
these patients. Dr. Gilbert added that the patients also suffered internal burns. This description
was confirmed to the Mission by Palestinian surgeons.
907. The Mission understands such injuries to be compatible with the impact of DIME
weapons. DIME weapons consist of a carbon-fibre casing filled with a homogeneous mixture of
an explosive material and small particles, basically a powder, of a heavy metal, for instance, a
tungsten alloy. Upon detonation of the explosive, the casing disintegrates into extremely small,
non-lethal fibres. The tungsten powder tears apart anything it hits. The impact of such weapons
in general causes very severe wounds within a relatively limited diameter (compared to other
projectiles) from the point of detonation. As the small heavy metal particles can slice through
soft tissue and bone, survivors close to the lethal zone may have their limbs amputated and
tungsten alloy particles embedded in their bodies. The probabilities of injuries to persons at a
greater distance from the detonation point are reduced compared to more conventional
projectiles. It is therefore also referred to as a “focused lethality munition”.489
486
See Abduldayem case in chapter XI.
William Kokinakis and Joseph Sperrazza, “Criteria for incapacitating soldiers with fragments and flechettes (U)”,
Ballistic Research Laboratories Report Number 1269, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Maryland (January 1965).
487
Mads Gilbert and Eric Fosse, “Inside Gaza’s al-Shifa hospital”, The Lancet, vol. 373, No. 9659 (17 January
2009), p. 200.
488
The DIME munitions subject of discussion here are distinct from the missile described, for example, in the
al Maqadmah mosque case. In that case the missile had been fitted with a micro-shrapnel fragmentation sleeve. The
489
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents