A/HRC/12/48
page 198
908. The materials submitted to the Mission, including by the expert witness Lt. Col. Lane,
point to specific medical concerns with regard to survivors of DIME weapon injuries.490 The
tungsten alloy particles are suspected to be highly carcinogenic and so small that they cannot be
extracted from the patient’s body. Dr. Gilbert noted that there had been no follow-up studies on
the survivors of this type of amputation observed in Gaza and Lebanon since 2006 following
Israeli military operations. There is some research suggesting that these patients might be at
increased risk of cancer. These concerns apply equally to missile or projectile shrapnel of heavy
metal such as tungsten or tungsten alloy which was used in at least two occasions in Gaza. The
carcinogenic hazards are the same no matter the delivery means or the size or shape of the pieces
of the metal that enter human flesh.
D.
Factual findings on the use of munitions causing a specific type of injury
909. From the facts it gathered, the Mission finds that the allegations that DIME weapons were
used by the Israeli armed forces in Gaza during the military operations require further
clarification with regard to their use and, particularly, the health-care needs of survivors of the
amputations attributed to DIME weapons.
910. The Mission notes that DIME or heavy metal shrapnel weapons and weapons armed with
heavy metal are not prohibited under international law as it currently stands. The “focused
lethality” reportedly pursued in the development of DIME weapons could be seen as advancing
compliance with the principle of distinction. The Mission also observes, however, that there
remains a very high risk of harming civilians when using these weapons in built-up areas and
that concerns have been expressed that DIME weapons could have a particularly adverse impact
on the enjoyment of the right to health of survivors, which would go beyond the impact generally
associated with being affected by anti-personnel weapons in an armed conflict.
E.
Allegations regarding the use of depleted and non-depleted uranium
munitions by the Israeli armed forces
911. The Mission received submissions and reviewed reports alleging the use of depleted
uranium weapons by the Israeli armed forces during the military operations in Gaza.491 While it
cannot be excluded that such weapons were used, on the basis of the information received the
Mission decided not to investigate the matter further.
912. The Mission also received a submission which alleged that the analysis of the air filter
taken from an ambulance which was in operation in the Beit Lahia area during the military
micro-shrapnel consisted of tungsten or tungsten alloy cubes, which may have similar carcinogenic hazards as the
powder or fibres in DIME.
490
Written submissions to the Mission by expert witness Lt. Col. Lane.
Arab Commission for Human Rights, Action des citoyens pour le désarmement nucléaire and International
Coalition Against War Criminals, Preliminary report, Mission for Gaza, April 2009 by Jean-François Fechino, pp.
55-60; Action des citoyens pour le désarmement nucléaire, On the use of radioactive weapons in the Gaza Strip
during « Operation Cast Lead » (27 December 2008 - 18 January 2009), http://www.acdn.net/.
491
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents