A/HRC/41/43/Add.3
22.
Thailand finds that the case of the dam collapse at the Xe Pian Xe Namnoy
hydropower project is irrelevant and an isolated incident and should not be included in the
Report of the Working Group.
23.
The case mentioned in para. 31 of the Report of the Working Group is still under
investigation, so the facts related to the case should be fairly referenced. Any and all
prejudicial statements should also be avoided as the case is now sub judice.
Human rights defenders and civic space (Paras. 32-47)
24.
Thailand continues to attach importance to the promotion and protection of the
rights of human rights defenders and freedom of expression. Recent amendments of the
Criminal Procedure Code to include Sections 161/1 and 165/2 provide the courts with an
overarching tool to protect the right to freedom of expression against Strategic
Litigation against Public Participation (SLAPP) and to reinforce a safe and enabling
environment for human rights defenders to conduct their work.
25.
Thailand is particularly concerned about the Working Group’s mislabeling of cases
involving Mr. Andy Hall, workers and NGOs and two Thai companies, namely, Natural
Fruit and Thammakaset, as SLAPP cases. Thailand is also concerned about the unjust
depiction/disapproval/deploration of the Working Group on the courts’ sanctions of Mr.
Hall as well as the misrepresentation of the factual background of these highly complex
cases.
26.
Thailand reaffirms that the Thai judicial system adheres to the principle of
independence and non-discrimination and Thailand’s defamation laws, both in principle
and in practice, are consistent with the ICCPR. Under Thailand’s jurisprudence, general
defamation or libel (published false statement) aim to protect the people’s legitimate
interest and reputation. They are not to be misused, abused, exploited or subjected to
hatred. At the same time, it is important to maintain a balance with the provisions to
safeguard those accused of defamation who act in good faith including defense through
proven truth or fair comment on any person or thing subjected to public criticism.
27.
Thailand’s criminal procedures are in line with international standards, such as: (1)
‘Truth’, ‘good faith’, and ‘fair comment’ are legitimate defenses; (2) The principle of the
presumption of the defendant’s innocence is well respected as the plaintiff bears the burden
of proof with regard to both falsity and fact; (3) Private plaintiffs are required to prove a
‘prima facie’ case at the preliminary hearing before the case’s admission to trial. In
addition, if the defendant is found guilty, the Criminal Code sets a minimum punishment
for criminal defamation other than imprisonment, such as the granting of a probation period
for giving sentence, fines, or suspended prison sentences.
Suppression and prevention of human trafficking and forced
labour (Paras. 48-54)
28.
Thailand takes a holistic approach, aiming to streamline the anti-human trafficking
process while promoting effective coordination and cooperation between the relevant
agencies, the private sector, CSOs and all stakeholders. Thailand’s efforts are driven by the
5P approach: (1) Policy and legal framework, (2) Prosecution, (3) Protection, (4)
Prevention, and (5) Partnership. This is in order to address the problems of human
trafficking in a systematic and sustainable manner.
29.
Thailand is committed to continuously implementing laws and measures to counter
trafficking in persons, including the announcement of anti-trafficking in persons as a
national agenda in 2015 and the integration of all relevant agencies to combat trafficking in
persons. The United States’ Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report 2018 graduated Thailand
from Tier 2 Watch List to Tier 2. In addition, a number of pieces of legislation and
amended ministerial orders have been passed to sharpen penalties for convicted offenders
and to provide better protection for victims. The Royal Decree of 7 April 2019 clarifies the
definition of “forced labour” under the Act on the Prevention and Suppression of
5
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents