A/HRC/14/32
special measures for children. These include measures to reduce children’s vulnerability to
trafficking, notably by creating a protective environment for them, and also on the
identification and representation of child victims, on the protection of the private life and
identity of child victims, on the issue of residence permits for child victims in accordance
with the best interests of the child, and on non-return of child victims to a State if there is
any indication that return would not be in the best interests of the child. Furthermore,
repatriation programmes for child victims should include enjoyment of the right to
education and measures to secure adequate care or reception by the family or appropriate
care arrangements. One of the aggravating circumstances to be considered when
determining the penalty for the offence of trafficking is when the offence is committed
against children. Special protection measures are afforded to child victims during and after
investigation and prosecution. Lastly, during court proceedings special care should be taken
of children’s needs and their right to special protection measures.
95.
Finally, in her 2009 annual report, the OSCE Special Representative makes the
protection of children from trafficking her first priority. She posits the process of best
interest determination5 as a central tool in ensuring that all aspects of the child’s situation
are considered, insisting that this process must especially be made a prerequisite before a
child is returned or repatriated.
2.
Main challenges
96.
Cooperation efforts at the regional level have been successful in a number of areas
and have demonstrated the added value of tackling anti-trafficking problems from both
collective and local perspectives. However, many challenges still lie ahead and would
require to be addressed by regional mechanisms.
Victim-centred and human rights-based approach
97.
In some regions, cooperation efforts are mainly focused on investigating and
prosecuting trafficking crimes. While this is welcome, efforts should be made to prioritize
protection and assistance to victims. Efforts oriented at adopting new criminal laws and
enhancing cross-border judicial cooperation to prosecute traffickers are necessary but not
sufficient in themselves. Adopting a human rights-based approach to combating trafficking
allows countries to tackle this phenomenon in a comprehensive and effective way,6 putting
the rights of the victims at the centre of the process in accordance with international human
rights law. A human rights-based approach also allows for effective prosecution of
traffickers, putting the emphasis on the right to effective remedy for the victim. The right to
access effective legal remedies and the right to compensation for victims of trafficking have
received attention only from a few regional and subregional mechanisms.
Gender perspective and the situation of men
98.
In addition to addressing the particular risks faced by women and children, a genderbased approach also requires all stakeholders to consider the specific situation of men.
Gender misconceptions often lead authorities not to consider men as possible victims of
trafficking. As a consequence, men as victims of trafficking tend to be discriminated
against in access to protection and assistance. This is reflected in the fact that a number of
regional cooperation initiatives only cover trafficking in women and children, while
trafficking in men and boys is not addressed.
5
6
18
For a comprehensive explanation of this process, see the UNHCR Guidelines on Determining the Best
Interests of the Child, May 2008.
See the OHCHR Guidelines.
GE.10-13211
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents