A/HRC/25/65
Without a trace
26.
Defectors who participated in mass arrests as well as survivors revealed that in the
majority of cases, the officers in charge of the initial arrest took the abductees to the
premises of their respective security or military branches. Despite the organised nature of
the arrests and detentions, authorities often failed to record the personal details of detainees,
including those who died in detention, making it difficult to trace them and inform their
families. The family of a person arrested in Idlib in September 2011 attempted to determine
his whereabouts. The interviewee described how “Wherever they searched, the authorities
said that his name was not recorded”.
27.
A defector told of a mass arrest in Jisr Al Shoughour, Idlib in June 2011, where
those detained were taken to a school that was used as an ad hoc detention facility. There,
detainees were subjected to painful and humiliating physical treatment. Their names were
never registered rendering any attempts to determine their whereabouts futile. In late
August 2011, officers of the Military Security in Latakia arrested four family members of
an interviewee and took them to an unknown location. Three weeks later, a young man who
was arrested together with the interviewee’s cousins informed him that his relatives had
been transferred to the military hospital of Latakia. Upon inquiry, it was discovered that
their names never appeared in the hospital’s registry.
Anti-Government armed groups
28.
In 2013, specific anti-Government armed groups adopted a practice of hostagetaking, targeting civilians perceived to be supporting the Government, human rights
defenders, journalists and religious leaders. The emergence of a pattern of abductions and
arbitrary deprivation of liberty has characterized the ever-growing presence of certain
armed groups, particularly in northern Syria.
29.
The fear of such kidnappings and hostage-takings has gripped the civilian
populations living under the control of certain armed groups. The perpetrators seize, detain
and threaten to kill their victims in order to coerce a third party – whether the families of
the kidnapped, their communities or the Syrian authorities – to fulfill their conditions for
the release of the hostage. Such acts, motivated by material gain and extortion, intimidate
and coerce the families of the kidnapped and their communities.
30.
Hostages are taken with the intent to instrumentalise their liberty and security for
ransom or prisoner exchange. Such offenses leave families in a state of uncertainty
regarding the whereabouts of their relatives, but do not amount to enforced disappearances
as the fate of the victims is not denied or concealed. In the current context in Syria, such
conduct may amount to war crimes.
31.
Information collected in recent months indicates that opposition armed groups such
as the Islamic State of Iraq and Al Sham (ISIS) have taken control of territory in northern
Syria and begun to adopt practices, such as incommunicado detention, that may lead to
disappearances. In one incident, armed men believed to be members of ISIS were reported
to have abducted two civilians on grounds of non-adherence to their interpretation of
Islamic dress code. The group later denied holding them in captivity. The whereabouts of
the detainees remain unknown.
40
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents