A/HRC/14/22
73.
In many settings, for a tort claim to be initiated, financial means and a defendant
who has money to pay for the damage are necessary. Other obstacles that women encounter
when trying to obtain damages against perpetrators through courts include: statutes of
limitations; inter-spousal and intrafamilial tort immunity rules; overly strict or inadequate
rules and interpretations of the causality link in the assessment of harms; and inadequate
evidence standards and procedures for quantifying damages which may have a negative
disparate impact on women (such as limiting compensation to economic loss, setting caps
on non-economic loss or measuring loss solely or primarily based on the loss of future
earning capacity measured through statistical evaluation). Insurance schemes may not be
effective either because basic coverage is usually restricted to compensatory damages —
which often do not cover intentional torts or exempt claims against spouses — or because
claims have to be brought during the term of the policy.
74.
In Europe, States that have ratified the European Convention on the Compensation
of Victims of Violent Crimes are obliged to provide compensation for victims and their
dependants when such compensation cannot be fully obtained by other means and when the
offender cannot be prosecuted or punished. The Convention does not include a specific
gendered perspective of the crimes considered and only covers material damages and not
non-economic loss. Since loss of earnings for women tends to be lower, leaving out noneconomic loss might affect women more negatively than men.
75.
Some States, in their legislation and jurisprudence, and some regional human rights
courts have started to recognize State responsibility for providing reparation to victims in
cases of lack of due diligence, while other States have begun to endorse the categories of
reparations of international human rights law. Others are compelling public officials to do
more systematic research on the effects of violence against women and the efficiency of the
measures to prevent and repair them.
76.
At the international level, a groundbreaking development is introduced in the Statute
of the International Criminal Court, in which it is provided that the Court may award
reparations other than restitution to victims, namely, restitution, compensation and
rehabilitation. In addition, the Rome Statute provides for the establishment of a trust fund
for the benefit of victims of crimes and their families, within the jurisdiction of the Court.
The Trust Fund provides for the possibility for victims and their families to receive
assistance separate and prior to a conviction from the Court, through the use of resources
raised through voluntary contributions. Since the Court has not awarded any reparations as
yet, it is too early to assess the degree to which it has protected women’s right to
reparations.
(a)
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights
77.
In November 2009 the Inter-American Court ruled in what will undoubtedly become
a landmark case in the field of reparations for women: Cotton Field v. Mexico.13 This case
concerns the abduction, killing and sexual violence of two minors and a young woman by
non-State actors in 2003, and the subsequent failure of the State to diligently investigate,
prosecute and punish the perpetrators and to treat the relatives of the deceased in a dignified
way. The Court found that the State of Mexico violated the rights to life, freedom, personal
integrity, access to justice and legal remedies and the right not to be discriminated against
on the grounds of sex under the American Convention. It also considered that Mexico had
infringed its obligations by failing to apply due diligence to prevent, investigate and impose
penalties for violence against women or its duty to provide adequate responses in the legal
system to punish and eradicate violence against women, thereby infringing the Inter-
13
GE.10-13109
Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Cotton Field v. Mexico, 16 November 2009.
19
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents