A/HRC/43/49
guilt, often exacerbated by anxiety about social exclusion, self-hatred and suicidal
tendencies. As with other methods, therefore, it is the intentionality and purposefulness of
degrading treatment, and the powerlessness of the victim, which are decisive for its
categorization as either torture or other ill-treatment.40
4.
Environmental orientation (sensory manipulation)
53.
Sensory stimuli and environmental control are a basic human need. Deliberate
sensory manipulation and disorientation through sensory deprivation or hyperstimulation
involves both the sensory organs and the cognitive processing of sensory perception.
Sensory hyperstimulation, in particular, is thus at the very interface between physical and
psychological torture.
54.
While short-term sensory deprivation alone can trigger extreme mental torment,
prolonged deprivation generally produces apathy, followed by progressively severe
disorientation, confusion and, ultimately, delusional, hallucinatory and psychotic
symptoms. Accordingly, the Body of Principles for Protection of All Persons under Any
Form of Detention or Imprisonment explicitly prohibits holding a detainee “in conditions
which deprive him, temporarily or permanently, of the use of any of his natural senses, such
as sight or hearing, or of his awareness of place and the passing of time”.41 In practice, such
deprivation involves the partial or complete elimination of sensory stimulation through an
accumulation of measures such as:
• Suppression of oral communication with the victim
• Constant monotonous light
• Visually sterile environment
• Sound-proof insulation of the cell
• Hooding
• Blindfolding
• Use of gloves
• Use of facial masks
• Use of earmuffs
55.
Sensory hyperstimulation below the threshold of physical pain, such as through
constant bright light, loud music, bad odours, uncomfortable temperatures or intrusive
white noise, induces progressively severe mental stress and anxiety, inability to think
clearly, followed by increasing irritability, outbursts of anger and, ultimately, total
exhaustion and despair. Extreme sensory hyperstimulation which, immediately or with the
passage of time, causes actual physical pain or injury should be regarded as physical
torture. This may include, for example, blinding victims with extremely bright light, or
exposing them to extremely loud noise or music, or to extreme temperatures causing burns
or hypothermia.
5.
Social and emotional rapport (isolation, exclusion, betrayal)
56.
A routine method of psychological torture is to attack the victim’s need for social
and emotional rapport, through isolation, social exclusion, mobbing and betrayal. Persons
deprived of meaningful social contact and subjected to emotional manipulation can quickly
become deeply destabilized and debilitated.
57.
The predominant method of isolation and social exclusion is solitary confinement,
which is defined as “the confinement of prisoners for 22 hours or more a day without
meaningful human contact”.42 Under international law, solitary confinement may be
40
41
42
See also, Cakal, “Debility, dependency and dread”, pp. 23–24.
General Assembly resolution 43/173, annex.
The Nelson Mandela Rules, rule 44.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents