A/HRC/31/74
meanings and identities that travelled across different mediums, national borders and
commercial markets. As a site of interracial competition, cooperation, and antagonism,
sport had played a profound role in civil rights, and social justice struggles in North
America and across the globe. She addressed several issues of access and inclusion in her
presentation.
123. She said that sport is a complex and contradictory space, for it is a place where the
presence and success of one or two Indigenous or racial minority female athletes is seen as
evidence of equality — or of the absence of racism — rather than exceptions to systemic
racial exclusion and racial tension. The expert then explained the relationship between
gender and sport focusing on the perception that athleticism and femininity could not be
combined. She then offered specific examples of athletes that encountered discrimination
because of gender, belonging to an indigenous group, geographical origin, different belief
systems etc. The pattern of exclusions seemed to profit a privileged culture that did not
accept minority participation in sport. Funding opportunities (scholarships) seemed to
further that status. There was also a scarcity of minority women as coaches, she said. Race
class and gender informed our opinions. A lack of visibility in sport reflected a larger social
injustice. It was clear that the public, media, and sport officials use a vocabulary
reminiscent of the dehumanization of black women during slavery equating their
physicality and athletic performance to that of men or animals. She referred to the
experiences of famous African-American tennis and basketball players such as Venus and
Serena Williams and their experiences with racism and gender bias.
124. Ms. Douglas stated that racism in sport was an area that had not been routinely
acknowledged in North American dialogues, and stressed the importance of the topic as it
magnified racism and helped sustain racism in society. Racism in sport therefore, was an
important human rights issue. The expert then recommended three possible areas of United
Nations involvement. First, society needed to have some understanding of what racism
involved — and to recognize its diversity and complexity. In turn, our responses had to be
multidimensional and expansive; society had to acknowledge it was not an individual
problem, but a social issue. Second, society needed useful research on the topic for
analysing the relationship between racism and sport in order to define ways to diversify
society. Finally, the expert said that it was clear that media and sport institutions did not
correspond to the multiracial, pluri-cultural and pluri-lingual characteristics of North
American populations. As a way of redressing this imbalance, legislation could be
developed and applied to sport governing bodies — inter and intra-nationally, including:
FIFA, FIBA, IAAF and IOC.
125. The representative of the United States appreciated the elaboration on different
forms of discrimination and intersectionality by the expert, including groups such as
African Americans, women, Asian, indigenous, and LGBT persons. He asked how to
address the difference that she noted in perceptions between black and white sport
successes, and queried whether the expert had any optimism or thoughts regarding how to
improve the situation.
126. The expert stated that systemic exclusion and disparate racial standards needed to be
addressed by societal education. She then contrasted similarities and differences between
forms of discrimination and emphasized the need for visibility across all forms of
discrimination. The expert added that she did have hope on this topic and stressed the need
to acknowledge the current state of racial circumstances in order to move forward.
127. The representative of South Africa referred to social media and queried whether
North American legislative policies have addressed discrimination in social media. In
response, Ms. Douglas noted that the United States and Canada exhibited political
difference regarding free speech. The expert stated that online bullying was an issue that
had been addressed in Canada, but she was unaware of any examples of government
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents