A/HRC/44/41/Add.1
essential for both intracommunal and intercommunal reconciliation. Greater trust of
communities in the criminal justice system, increased knowledge of communities about the
fate of perpetrators and victims, and effective reparations would contribute to building a sense
of safety and justice within communities which are essential for the promotion of
reconciliation, enabling the safe, dignified and sustainable return of internally displaced
persons.
64.
While the Government of Iraq has made significant efforts to prosecute ISIL fighters
for the atrocities committed, a number of concerns have been raised. In a joint report, UNAMI
and OHCHR expressed concern that basic fair trial guarantees were not being respected in
these trials, and that terrorism charges were too broad, referring simply to “membership” or
“association” to a terrorist group, resulting in family members of ISIL fighters, including
women and children who cooked for them, being prosecuted without consideration for their
specific contribution to crimes by ISIL and for the voluntary or coerced nature of their
association. 21 Moreover, anti-terrorism legislation does not cover all relevant crimes,
particularly international crimes and conflict-related sexual violence, leading to calls for new
legislation in Iraq, 22 and for acts of sexual violence to be prosecuted as standalone crimes
(S/2018/250, para. 46). With the support of the international community, including the United
Nations Investigative Team to Promote Accountability for Crimes Committed by Da’esh/ISIL,
Iraq must tackle the need for justice and accountability for the crimes of ISIL, in full respect
for fair trial guarantees, including double jeopardy issues, and with a focus on the human rights
violations committed.
65.
Lastly, the participation of internally displaced persons in decisions that affect them is
paramount for stabilization, and must be inclusive of persons of all ethnic and religious groups,
sexes and age groups, and persons with disabilities. Participation is essential in the design of
policies aimed at meeting their assistance and protection needs, supporting returns and other
forms of durable solutions, and in processes to ensure accountability for crimes committed
during the conflict, and to promote national reconciliation and social cohesion.
66.
The upcoming parliamentary elections, crucial for the political transition of the country,
will require the genuine and full political participation of internally displaced persons and
returnees. The recent inclusion of internally displaced persons in the latest elections in Iraq is
an excellent development in their political enfranchisement, but that experience points to areas
that require improvement in the next elections. The genuine participation of internally
displaced persons and returnees in the next elections can provide an opportunity for Iraqi
society to transition to peace and for the reintegration of internally displaced persons and
returnees in sustainable political, economic and social life.
67.
There is a general sense in Iraq that the recent demonstrations in the country have
overshadowed other matters from the attention of the Government of Iraq. The human rights
situation of internally displaced persons in Iraq is however not an isolated issue that can be put
aside; rather, it is at the core of the challenges that the country faces, and calls for an immediate
step-up in efforts for the promotion of humanitarian assistance, development and stabilization
approaches, and social cohesion, justice and reconciliation. The invitation extended to the
Special Rapporteur by the Government and its willingness to engage with her mandate is
testament to its political will to address displacement issues. The Government’s recognition of
the need for reconciliation and social cohesion is also encouraging. Efforts must, however, be
scaled up further. There can be no true recovery possible for Iraq without addressing the human
rights situation of internally displaced persons. The achievement of durable solutions for them
will require the State to address its long-standing and deeply entrenched sectarian and ethnic
tensions.
21
22
14
OHCHR and UNAMI, “Human Rights in the Administration of Justice in Iraq: Trials under the antiterrorism laws and implications for justice, accountability and social cohesion in the aftermath of ISIL”,
January 2020.
See for example the third report of the Special Adviser and Head of the United Nations Investigative
Team to Promote Accountability for Crimes Committed by Da’esh/Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant
(S/2019/878), para. 96.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents