A/HRC/9/12
page 6
I. THE CURRENT POLITICAL AND IDEOLOGICAL CONTEXT
6.
The defamation of religions is part of a disturbing worldwide trend marked by the rise of
racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, with its roots in the current
political and ideological context. This context is characterized by five major forms of intellectual
drift: the equation of the factors of race, culture and religion; a hierarchical rather than dialectical
and complementary interpretation of human rights; suspicion of religion; rejection of diversity;
and, finally, an excessive emphasis on the factors of identity and security reflecting a defensive
and exclusive approach.
7.
In his previous reports, the Special Rapporteur underlined that this political and ideological
context is marked by three powerful tendencies apparent in all regions of the world. The most
serious current manifestation of the regression in the struggle against racism is the resurgence of
racist and xenophobic violence in the world. This tendency finds expression in particular in acts
of physical violence perpetrated by extremist, neo-Nazi and nationalist groups targeting
religious, ethnic or cultural communities.
8.
The second powerful trend highlighted by the Special Rapporteur in his recent reports to
the Council and the General Assembly involves the political banalization and democratic
legitimization of racism and xenophobia. In particular, the Special Rapporteur notes with
disquiet the way in which political parties preaching racist and xenophobic platforms manage to
introduce and implement these ideas by means of government alliances that guarantee them a
place on the political stage and access to the apparatus of the State. This democratic
legitimization of racism currently represents the most serious threat to democracy and human
rights.
9.
The current political and ideological context is also strongly influenced by the intellectual
and scientific legitimization of racism, xenophobia and intolerance, which constitutes the third
major trend highlighted by the Special Rapporteur in the course of his term of office. This trend
is illustrated by a growing number of so-called scientific publications and declarations whose
stock-in-trade is historical stereotypes underlying prejudice and racist and xenophobic theories
and manifesting themselves in an ethnic, racial or religious interpretation of current problems.
Recent illustrations of this phenomenon include: the claims by Nobel Laureate in Medicine,
James Watson, that persons of African descent are intellectually inferior, reviving historical
stereotypes at the basis of anti-Black racism; the invitation to the negationist David Irving to
speak at the Oxford Union Debating Society; the association of Islam with violence; the
reductive association of Judaism with domination and power; and the identification of
Christianity with Western domination.
10. This process involving the intellectual legitimization of racism, xenophobia and religious
hatred springs from a deep-rooted rejection of multiculturalism and diversity, which is one of the
main sources of the resurgence of racist, xenophobic and antireligious violence worldwide. The
Special Rapporteur points out that, in ideological terms, the Manichean concept of the clash of
civilizations and religions - the implicit hierarchization of cultures, races, civilizations and the
mistrust of religions - represents the new ideological foundation for political and intellectual
elites and erstwhile Cold-War ideologues. The new international context of the fight against
terrorism has further strengthened the trend towards ideological polarization and the retreat into
separate identities.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents