A/HRC/16/52
notes that pretrial detention is often carried out for the purpose of extracting a confession
under torture. Experience shows that most acts of torture, and certainly the most cruel and
egregious, happen in the first few hours or days after a person’s arrest, and while he/she is
technically under preventive detention. In this respect, he recalls article 15 of the
Convention, and like his predecessors, recommends that no statement of confession made
by a person deprived of liberty, other than that made before a court, should be admissible or
be afforded probative value in any judicial proceeding.
65.
In order to identify structural methods of assisting States in developing, adopting
and fulfilling the above-mentioned obligations, the Special Rapporteur will encourage
Governments to reinforce their legislative norms through protocols, instruments and
methodological guides targeted at ensuring effective guarantees for persons deprived of
their liberty. These measures include effective realization of the right of detainees in
custody to challenge the lawfulness of their detention before an independent court (e.g., the
right to habeas corpus). Further, States should promote and apply non-custodial measures
such as bail and probation, respect medical inspection upon admission and compulsory
medical inspection during transfer, and introduce video and audio recordings of
proceedings in interrogation rooms. There must be formal procedures by which a detainee
is informed of his/her rights, including the right to remain silent and to consult a lawyer, as
well as effective sanctions for failure to respect these rights. The Special Rapporteur
recognizes the importance of continuing dialogue with States with a view to strengthening
legislative mechanisms aimed at preventing torture and ill-treatment in pretrial detention.
He notes that various mandate holders have expressed concerns about pretrial detention,
and undertakes to hold further discussions with them in order to identify and promote best
practices on measures to prevent, punish and eradicate torture and other ill-treatment in
pretrial detention. This will also be done by using fact-finding country visits and
information provided by reliable sources to identify challenges and illustrate good
practices.
F.
Conditions in detention
66.
In previous reports11, conditions of detention have been documented extensively
based on information received from various sources, in particular, factual observations
made as a result of fact-finding missions. The Special Rapporteur is deeply concerned by
the large number of places of detention that do not meet minimum international standards.
He plans to engage with States that permit such conditions as well as with those that lack
the ability or resources to institute minimum standards. He will seek to address the
systematic deprivation of the most basic human rights standards relating to conditions of
detention, including those related to food, water, clothing, health care and minimum space,
as well as hygiene, privacy and security necessary for a humane and dignified existence, as
conditions that in and of themselves can constitute cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
G.
Torture in secret detention
67.
The Special Rapporteur recalls General Assembly resolution 60/148, and Council
resolution 8/8, both stating that prolonged incommunicado detention or detention in secret
places may facilitate the perpetration of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading
treatment or punishment, and could in themselves constitute a form of such treatment.
11
A/HRC/13/39/Add.5
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents