A/HRC/43/21
comment on enquiries by Israeli media regarding the delay between the ramming and the
shooting.20 The Forces opened an operational inquiry into the incident. 21
13.
In other cases, the use of lethal force led to severe and permanent injuries. On 12 July
2019, the Israeli security forces shot and critically injured a nine-year-old Palestinian boy in
the head during the weekly demonstrations in Kafr Qaddum, near Qalqiliya. According to
eyewitnesses, protesters were throwing stones at the Israeli security forces about 150 metres
away from where the boy was standing at the entrance of a friend’s house when he was hit.
At the time of reporting, the boy remained hospitalized with around 100 fragments lodged in
the brain, unable to speak and with very limited ability to move. Media reported that Israel
Defense Forces was investigating the incident, however this has not been officially
confirmed.22
III. Update on accountability
A.
Accountability for the 2014 escalation of hostilities in Gaza and other
rounds of hostilities
14.
Over five years after the 2014 escalation of hostilities in Gaza, lack of accountability
remains pervasive for suspected violations of international humanitarian law, including
allegations of war crimes perpetrated by all parties to the conflict. Since the publication of
the report of the commission of inquiry on the 2014 Gaza conflict, 23 the Secretary-General
and the High Commissioner have provided regular updates on the lack of progress regarding
the implementation of the recommendations contained in that report, and highlighted
concerns about the lack of accountability by both Israeli and Palestinian authorities.24
15.
With respect to Israel, the most recent update by the Israeli Military Advocate General
was provided on 15 August 2018 and referred to in the previous report of the High
Commissioner. 25 No notable progress in the investigation and prosecution of alleged
violations in the context of the 2014 round of hostilities was registered during the reporting
period.26
16.
Lack of progress and transparency persists also in relation to accountability efforts
linked to previous rounds of hostilities. In particular, since July 2010, no information has
been made available by the Government of Israel in relation to progress in the investigation
and prosecution of alleged wrongdoing committed by the Israeli security forces in the context
of Operation Cast Lead.27
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
www.timesofisrael.com/9-days-after-alleged-car-ramming-eyewitnesses-say-israel-hasnt-contactedthem/.
www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-palestinian-car-hit-soldiers-they-shot-back-once-fourminutes-later-nine-bullets-followed-1.7045801.
www.timesofisrael.com/family-of-palestinian-boy-shot-in-the-head-wants-answers-from-israel/.
A/HRC/29/52.
See, in particular, A/HRC/34/38, para. 42, A/HRC/37/41, paras. 9–17, A/HRC/40/43, paras. 4–13,
and A/71/364 paras. 40 and 51–55.
A/HRC/40/43, para. 5.
In particular, of the 500 complaints (relating to 360 incidents) referred to the Military Advocate
General, 31 were referred for criminal investigation and most were closed on the ground that the
conduct of the Israeli security forces complied with domestic and international law. While one
investigation led to the conviction of three soldiers for looting, investigations in 28 cases did not
result in criminal charges; two cases remain pending. Cases relating to 189 incidents have so far been
closed. See https://mfa.gov.il/MFA/ForeignPolicy/IsraelGaza2014/Documents/Operation-ProtectiveEdge-MAG-Corps-Press-Release-Update-6-15-August-2018.pdf and A/HRC/40/43 paras. 5 and 9.
According to the latest available update, 47 military police investigations have been opened and led to
the indictment of three Israeli soldiers (two of whom for forcing a Palestinian minor to assist them in
a manner that put him at risk and another for killing a Palestinian civilian) and to the conviction of
one soldier for the theft of a credit card. See https://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA%20Gallery/
Documents/GazaUpdateJuly2010.pdf.
5
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents