A/HRC/42/47/Add.2
create a coordination body at the federal level to assess the best legal, political and
budgetary strategies to provide access to adequate public water and sanitation services for
those who are undocumented, stateless or otherwise in an irregular situation. Such an
assessment must include the conditions of toilets and access to water in detention and
reception centres.
G.
Prisoners and detainees
54.
The Special Rapporteur spoke to three refugee men who were in prison. Their
stories indicate poor and almost inhuman conditions of access to water and toilets in prison.
He visited several blocks in Kajang Prison and observed varying levels of privacy for toilet
usage. In most blocks, particularly those used for rehabilitation, the toilet inside each cell
was located next to a low wall separating other parts of the cell. However, there were also
blocks, particularly the Quarantine Block, where that wall did not exist and prisoners were
left without any privacy when urinating or defecating.
55.
The Special Rapporteur acknowledges the efforts of the public authorities to provide
safe water and sanitation to detainees and highlights that their needs must be a continuous
concern, taking note of the requirements of international humanitarian law and the United
Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela
Rules).5 The Nelson Mandela Rules stipulates that drinking water should be available and
that prisoners are required to keep their persons clean, and to this end they should be
provided with water and with such toilet articles as are necessary for health and cleanliness.
H.
Transgender and gender non-conforming persons
56.
Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex persons in Malaysia often face
structural and systemic discrimination. Particularly under the civil and State-administered
Sharia laws, there are many laws that criminalize persons based on sexual orientation,
gender identity and gender expression. In his report on gender inequality in 2016, the
Special Rapporteur emphasized that restrictive gender recognition laws not only severely
undermined the ability of transgender persons to enjoy their rights to basic services, they
also prevented them from living safely, free from violence and discrimination
(A/HRC/33/49, para. 9).
57.
Water and sanitation facilities must be safe, available, accessible, affordable, and
socially and culturally acceptable, provide privacy and ensure dignity for all individuals,
including transgender and gender non-conforming persons. These elements should be
particularly prioritized in public spaces and the work environment. The Special Rapporteur
heard that several transgender persons were often instructed by their employers to use
toilets based on their sex assigned at birth, mostly due to complaints by co-workers or
clients. As a result, transgender persons cannot use the closest toilet but are forced to use
toilets on other floors in other buildings or in public spaces. According to a 2017 online
survey on access to toilets by transgender persons in Malaysia by Justice for Sisters, 40 of
the 97 transgender respondents had encountered discrimination of some form when using a
public toilet, while 26 of the 97 respondents had experienced restrictions on access to toilets
at the workplace. Fifteen of the transgender respondents reported having been forced to use
toilets based on their sex assigned at birth.6
58.
Working in such environments not only adds stress, anxiety and isolation, but also
increases health risks, such as urinary tract infections, due to restricted use of toilets. In the
above-mentioned survey, 42 per cent of the respondents reported that they felt emotional
stress about using the toilet, whereas 39 per cent of them battled with self-esteem issues
because of discriminatory experiences encountered when going to the toilet. In many cases,
5
6
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, general comment No. 15 (2002) on the right to
water, para. 16 (g).
The findings of the survey were reported at a symposium on access to public facilities for transgender
persons, held in Penang in January 2017.
13
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents