A/HRC/7/15
page 10
this definition were to be recast as a combination of income poverty, human development
poverty and social exclusion. On the contrary, it would enormously improve the relevance of the
“lack of basic security” in defining extreme poverty.
39. Similarly, capability poverty, which has now been broadly accepted in human development
literature, can also be regarded as the simultaneous deprivation of income, human development
and social exclusion. In fact, Amartya Sen’s definition of capability “as freedom to lead a life
one has reasons to choose” is clearly multidimensional and combines income and human
development as components of capability, both as constituent and instrumental variables, with
social exclusion adding the relational dimension of poverty.
40. Extreme poverty, as a combination of income poverty, human development poverty and
social exclusion, is not just a question of severity and intensity of poverty; it is a concept that
considers poverty a denial of human rights, thus mobilizing public action towards the adoption of
public policies by Government.
C. Added value of a human rights framework
41. There is a significant added value to invoking a human rights framework in policies to
eradicate poverty. It adds the appeal that basic human rights are usually recognized as highly
valuable objectives that all individuals are inherently entitled to. This has two implications. First,
if poverty is considered a violation of human rights, it could mobilize public action, which itself
could contribute significantly to the adoption of appropriate policies, especially by Governments
in democracies. It is basically the obligations that are entailed by human rights, the deprivation
of which is recognized as poverty that changes the nature of the discourse of economic
development, making poverty-removal a principal objective. Second, human rights obligations
are binding, and the authorities must be able to demonstrate that they have made their best efforts
to fulfil those rights by adopting appropriate policies that have the greatest likelihood of
achieving those results.
42. The independent expert summed it up in his second report when he stated that, when
concentrating on extreme poverty, it should be possible to invoke the associated obligations
more generally, with the duty-bearers finding it difficult or improper to reject the appeals to the
related obligation.
43. As a first step, it is often easiest to call for the fulfilment of the human rights that have
been recognized through international human rights law or national domestic legislation. The
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights has accorded this legal
recognition to the right to food, health, education, social security and an adequate standard of
living. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights has recognized the right to
association, information, freedom of expression and so on. If, in a social arrangement, these
rights are fulfilled, it is difficult to imagine that there will be any poverty in that society.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents