A/HRC/7/15
page 22
budgeting. Most of the countries in sub-Saharan Africa (except Mali, Mauritania, the Niger and
Gambia) have put a lot of effort into systematic reporting, but monitoring and evaluation results
have not been effectively integrated.26
84. To conform to human rights principles, the monitoring and evaluation system has to be
participatory in nature. Civil society has been actively involved in participatory poverty
assessments during the preparation of poverty reduction strategy papers, but much less in
subsequent implementation, monitoring and evaluation. Though all strategy papers acknowledge
some role for non-governmental organizations in the official monitoring system, only a few
countries, such as Malawi and Uganda, acknowledge their function as independent watchdogs. In
Gambia, the Government is developing methods for increasing the participation of civil society
in order to identify budgetary priorities, tracking of budget spending to key sectors and
monitoring of the quality of public services at the national level. In Mozambique, the Action
Plan for the Reduction of Absolute Poverty established poverty observatories at the central and
provincial levels, which institutionalized the participation of civil society in monitoring poverty
reduction strategy papers.
VII. DRAFT GUIDING PRINCIPLES
85. The Sub-Commission for the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights developed a
comprehensive set of draft guiding principles, entitled “Extreme poverty and human rights: the
rights of the poor”, which incorporated various relevant international instruments, building on
international efforts and ongoing work in other forums, including the reports by the independent
experts on the right to development and on extreme poverty.
86. The draft guiding principles recognize that extreme poverty and social exclusion constitute
a violation of human dignity, and thus require prioritization in national and international policies
for its eradication. They give great importance to the right to participation and encourage States
to foster it through empowerment, thereby enabling the poor to become genuine partners in their
development. They further recognize that all human rights are indivisible, interdependent and
universal. The guiding principles focus on rights that have already been recognized in
international instruments, such as the right to participate in public life, the right to fair justice
(incorporating the principles of equality before the law), economic and social rights. All States
and the international community are duty-bound to ensure these rights to everyone, especially
those suffering from extreme poverty. The draft guidelines suggest that the international
community has the additional task of providing a suitable international environment in areas of
trade, investment, market, debt and so on. Lastly, the guidelines also take into account
international human rights principles of non-discrimination, accountability and transparency and
direct specific policies to be targeted at the most vulnerable groups, such as women, children, the
elderly, persons with disabilities and the homeless.
87. The drafting of guiding principles dealing specifically with extreme poverty is a significant
step towards recognizing the multifaceted problems faced by those suffering from extreme
26
N. Holvet and Robrecht Renard (2007), “Monitoring and Evaluation Under the PRSP: Solid
rock or quicksand?”, Evaluation and Program Planning, Vol. 31, Issue 1, pp. 66-81.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents