A/HRC/35/36
up as women and vice versa, even the criminalization violates the person’s self-identified
gender.
53.
As noted in a recent UNHCR study:
The majority of laws criminalizing same-sex sexual activity were noted by
respondents in countries in Africa, Asia-Pacific, and the Middle East and North
Africa region, with a few offices also highlighting similar laws targeting transgender
identity. While many respondents in the Americas and Europe reported significant
progress to ensure adequate legal protection of the human rights of LGBTI persons,
there nonetheless remain some countries in these regions with laws that criminalize
core aspects of LGBTI expression …
While laws targeting LGBTI persons may be written to criminalize specific sexual
acts rather than the broader identities of persons with a diverse sexual orientation or
gender identity, some offices noted that such laws may nonetheless be used to
prosecute individuals who identify as LGBTI. A respondent in a country in the
Middle East and North Africa region reported, for instance, that “some LGBTI
people have been convicted by the authorities solely for their presumed sexual
orientation”, despite the fact that only same-sex activity, rather than LGBTI identity,
is criminalized in the country of operation.30
54.
There is thus a need to move towards decriminalization in respect of these laws,
which regrettably help to fuel the violence and discrimination.
B.
Effective anti-discrimination measures
55.
Many countries are still hampered by a lack of anti-discrimination measures or
insufficient anti-discrimination measures; this, too, is linked to environments that lead to
violence and discrimination. This is a longitudinal challenge, which starts in the home and
extends to the education system, the workplace, and life beyond. Some countries have
moved towards integrating sexual orientation and gender identity into their constitutions or
laws, directly or indirectly, while others have policies and programmes to reflect sexual and
gender diversity. Yet, within the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender setting, some
groups are particularly marginalized and may need special measures to help overcome
difficulties. For instance, transgender persons are often discriminated against at school and
this pushes them out of the educational set-up; they might then fall into a situation of
marginalization and then exploitation.
56.
The discrimination is also intersectional. There might be tints of patriarchy
impacting on women, which also impact negatively on lesbians and women who have sex
with women. There might be traces of racism, which also impact negatively on refugees
and migrants who are lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender. There might be hints of
extremism that impact negatively on those who wish to have their sexual orientation and
gender identity respected culturally. Even where there are laws to protect people from
discrimination, there might be weak implementation. This is further tested by issues such as
access to justice and mechanisms and/or personnel that could provide some assistance and
remedies, and the call for transparency and accountability. There is thus a need for effective
anti-discrimination measures of a comprehensive kind — not only formal but also
substantive, not only de jure but also de facto — in addition to the building of a community
that is open to understanding and that respects sexual and gender diversity.
30
16
UNHCR, “Protecting persons with diverse sexual orientations and gender identities: a global report
on UNHCR’s efforts to protect lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex asylum seekers and
refugees”, p. 13.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents