A/HRC/41/35/Add.2
Special Rapporteur since the visit. Table 1 contains a summary of the status of
implementation of the recommendations.
8.
Article 4 of the Broadcast Act remains in force, with the regulation of broadcast
media in line with the Act continuing to fall within the ambit of the Ministry of Internal
Affairs and Communications. The tensions created by this regulatory framework, with its
lack of institutional independence, have reportedly been accentuated by public pushback
from government officials against the work of critical journalists, including through
communications to a newspaper editorial board and a kisha club 1 concerning questions
posed by a journalist at government press conferences. To perform its role as a public
watchdog, the press must be free to pursue its own lines of reporting and investigation. The
State must refrain in all cases from stigmatizing journalists, regardless of whether the
content of their work may be perceived as critical or sensitive. To create a positive
environment for journalistic work, authorities at the highest level should publicly express
support for the work of independent, investigative journalists.
9.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the information received regarding steps taken by
civil society and journalist unions to foster solidarity among those within the profession. He
encourages such efforts, in particular in the light of additional information received relating
to reported decisions taken at the editorial level of a prominent Japanese newspaper, which
appear to have restricted the scope for its reporters to work on sensitive topics.
10.
Editorial pressure on journalists working on controversial issues, including historical
crimes committed by Japan and the use of “comfort women” in particular, has compounded
the continuing resistance of the authorities to civil society’s advocacy efforts in connection
with historical crimes. The Special Rapporteur reiterates his recommendation that the
Government accept a visit of the Special Rapporteur on the promotion of truth, justice,
reparation and guarantees of non-recurrence as a step towards building a positive
framework for dealing with the issue.
11.
Authorities have continued to place pressure and undue restrictions on peaceful
protesters in Okinawa. Specific concerns in this regard were raised in an official
communication to the State from several special procedure mandate holders on 28 February
2017, concerning the arrest and charging of Hiroji Yamashiro in connection with his
involvement in peaceful protests against the expansion of military bases in Okinawa. 2
Released on bail in March 2017, Mr. Yamashiro has since been convicted and sentenced to
two years of imprisonment with hard labour, suspended for three years. His appeal to the
Fukuoka High Court was recently rejected. In opinion No. 55/2018
(A/HRC/WGAD/2018/55), the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention declared Mr.
Yamashiro’s detention to be arbitrary and directly connected to his exercise of freedom of
expression and peaceful assembly. The Special Rapporteur expresses serious concern that
Mr. Yamashiro’s suspended sentence not only restricts him in any further exercise of his
rights, but risks proving a broader deterrent against the exercise of the right of freedom of
assembly. The freedoms of assembly and expression are closely linked and often mutually
reinforcing. The State must strengthen its commitment to fulfilling its human rights
obligations in these areas.
12.
The Government does not appear to have taken steps to address concerns raised
regarding the Act on the Protection of Specially Designated Secrets. The Special
Rapporteur reiterates the need to amend the Act and translate informal assurances that it
will not be used to target journalists into legally binding safeguards.
13.
Cumulatively, continued pressure on freedom of expression restricts access to
information and narrows the latitude for developing and sharing diverse political opinions.
The rights to freedom of opinion and expression have a direct, multifaceted impact on the
development of democracy, equality and societies in their entirety. The limitation or
1
2
Associations of print and broadcast journalists (see A/HRC/55/22/Add.1, para. 34).
See communication JPN 1/2017, available at
https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/Tmsearch/TMDocuments.
3
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents