A/HRC/45/CRP.11
• Interviews with victims, families, lawyers and witnesses with direct knowledge of
incidents;
• Legal case files and other verified confidential documents;
• Interviews with former Government and military officials and others with direct
knowledge of specific cases or of the internal workings of certain institutions
(insiders);
• Interviews with currently serving members of security forces conducted under strict
confidentiality;
• Verified digital information (in particular videos, satellite imagery or social media
content) containing direct information of an incident;
• Publicly available statements or information regarding relevant facts provided by
Government institutions and representatives (including televised statements or
statements posted on social media); and
• Laws, policies and directives of the Government in Venezuela.
15.
The Mission spoke with former Director General of the Bolivarian National
Intelligence Service (SEBIN), General Christopher Figuera. The Mission is aware of his
admitted role in the April 2019 coup attempt and his expressed intention to implicate
President Maduro in the perpetration of serious crimes. The Mission notes that it has not
received any information from the Government, despite requests, and therefore does not have
countervailing information contradicting the points alleged by General Figuera. On balance,
the Mission has relied on parts of the information provided by Mr. Figuera, cited throughout
the present report, on the basis of its applicable standard of proof. In doing so, the Mission
notes that other information received, including by other persons with inside information,
corroborates parts of the statements provided by Mr. Figuera and that the information
provided by General Figuera was, on its face, internally consistent and plausible.
16.
Due to time and resource limitations, the Mission has not been able to analyse all
contexts involving violations that could fall within its four mandated areas. This includes,
notably, violations within the Arco Minero region. It recommends further investigation into
allegations of serious human rights violations and crimes in this region, including against
indigenous peoples.2
17.
In its assessment of secondary information, the Mission endeavoured to interview the
researcher or author of the publication, submission or text to assess its credibility and the
methodology used. The reliability and credibility of each source was carefully assessed. The
Mission considered whether the source was trustworthy, consistently probing the veracity of
their statements. With respect to digital information, the Mission assessed the information’s
reliability, namely through objectively verifiable information, corroboration of dates and
times, visual comparison, comparing features of objects, persons and/or locations,
geolocation, chronolocation, and completeness, namely whether it captured the information
in its entirety and surrounding context.
18.
The Mission collected and preserved information in accordance with its mandate to
support accountability mechanisms. All information gathered by the Mission, including
information pertaining to individual perpetrators, was stored in safe platforms, with strict and
controlled access, applying best practices in terms of digital security and permanent control.
The Mission authorized OHCHR to provide access to the existing materials contained in the
database to competent authorities that carry out credible, impartial and independent
2
4
See e.g., Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, A/HRC/44/54, 15 July 2020, available
at:
https://www.ohchr.org/EN/HRBodies/HRC/RegularSessions/Session44/Documents/A_HRC_44_54_
UnofficialSpanishTranslation.pdf; Human Rights Watch, Venezuela: Violentos abusos en minas de
oro ilegales, 4 February 2020, available at: https://www.hrw.org/es/news/2020/02/04/venezuelaviolentos-abusos-en-minas-de-oro-ilegales; International Crisis Group, El peso del oro: violencia en
el sur de Venezuela, 28 February 2019, available at: https://www.crisisgroup.org/es/latin-americacaribbean/andes/venezuela/073-gold-and-grief-venezuelas-violent-south
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents