A/HRC/4/37
page 24
July 2006, the Special Representative wrote to the Government of the Philippines concerning the
killing of Annaliza Abanador-Gandia, a pro-democracy activist and leader of a womens’ rights
organization who had been followed by two unidentified men and shot dead. In October 2006,
the Special Representative wrote to the Government of Iraq concerning the alleged shooting
by 10 men of Faliha Ahmed Jabori, head of the women’s rights organization, Maternity and
Childhood, and to the Government of Russia concerning the murder of Anna Politkovskaia, a
prominent human rights defender and journalist.
103. In numerous cases from all regions, police, military or government officials are the
alleged perpetrators of violence, including sexual violence and death threats against women
human rights defenders. In February 2006, a joint communication was sent to the Government
of China concerning a housing rights activist and cyber dissident who was arrested by police. In
March and April 2006, joint communications were sent to the Government of the Sudan
concerning two cases where a humanitarian organization assisting women who have suffered
gender-based sexual violence as a result of the conflict in Darfur and an organization offering
legal aid to women were obstructed by the Humanitarian Aid Commission, a government
agency. In the first instance the organization was ordered to hand over all its assets and close its
health and nutrition centres and its food distribution unit. In the second case, the organization’s
assets were declared frozen because they had applied for funding from the European Union.
In April 2006, a joint communication was sent to the Government of Zimbabwe concerning
a 65-year-old human rights defender and former Chairwoman of the Porta Farm Residents’
Committee, who spoke out against forced evictions that took place in 2004 and 2005. She
received death threats and was allegedly threatened with expulsion from the community if she
continued to interact with human rights groups.
104. In her report on her visit to Brazil (A/HRC.4/37/Add. 2), the Special Representative has
reported on the plight of widows of rural workers who are now leading a movement. She was
deeply distressed at the allegation that elements opposing their work had resorted to labelling
them as prostitutes in an attempt to undermine their social credibility in communities where they
live and work.
IV. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
105. The progressive achievement of economic, social and cultural rights (ESCR) or the
obligation of the State being dependent on the availability of resources should not be
misunderstood as allowing States to adopt policies that violate these rights or negate the
probability of their realization. The Special Representative recommends appropriate
guarantees in national constitutions that give full legitimacy and recognition to activities
for the promotion and protection of these rights.
106. Where ESCR are expressed as principles of State policy in the national constitution
and not as fundamental rights, States must ensure that these principles are not deviated
from and that civil society actors have the full opportunity to participate in discussions of
social or economic policies or projects. In particular they must have the opportunity to
monitor the effects of such policies and projects, to register their objections and to receive
responses from the State with regard to any action that undermines the right to strive for
attaining these rights.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents