A/HRC/39/36
evidence about the benefits of force in psychiatry, and the fact that, on the contrary, several
findings documented negative experiences and lasting anger by those subjected to forced
treatment. It was concluded that human rights violations still took place in mental health
settings, which caused inequalities to proliferate, and that that was compounded by
intersecting identities. Any successful reform would require a change of heart within
psychiatric and clinical practice to move beyond the biomedical model of psychiatry.
D.
Improving practices to combat discrimination, stigma, violence,
coercion and abuse
32.
The panel was composed of representatives of the United Nations Population Fund
(UNFPA), the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), the International
Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Human Rights Watch, and Akershus University
Hospital, Norway. The panellists highlighted the centrality of mental health to general
health, human rights and dignity. All panellists agreed that in order to promote inclusion
and mental health, multiple forms of discrimination and inequality must be addressed —
relating to youth, women, persons living with HIV/AIDS, persons living in poverty,
persons living in rural regions, persons with disabilities including persons with
psychosocial disabilities, and other intersecting identities. The panellists promoted a
people-centred approach to empower communities as agents of change, by including rights
holders in the design and implementation of programmes and services and in the training
for them.
33.
Monica Ferro, of UNFPA, emphasized that mental health was a component of
sexual and reproductive health and rights, and that mental health issues could develop due
to lack of choice in reproductive decisions and could arise in connection with the
psychological dimensions of conception, pregnancy, childbirth, post-partum care, and
events relating to abortion, miscarriage, HIV/AIDS and female genital mutilation. She
suggested that mental health should be integrated into all sexual and reproductive health
and rights policies, strategies, programmes and statistics. She referred to the determinants
of mental health, and emphasized that gender discrimination often led to detrimental
impacts on women’s rights; for example, the increased likelihood of women being
subjected to sexual violence linked to the prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder
suffered by women; women’s higher rates of diagnosis with depression, compared to men
with identical symptoms; and the greater challenges for women in accessing reproductive
health services due to a lack of economic resources.
34.
Tim Martineau, of UNAIDS, emphasized that people living with HIV, like other
marginalized and stigmatized groups, faced significant levels of depression linked to the
fear of having their status disclosed, and to accessing treatment. Often, discrimination and
exclusion were exacerbated by other layers of identity, such as race, sexual orientation and
age, leading to further isolation and poorer health outcomes and the added risk of violence
and oppression due to widespread stigma. UNAIDS placed human rights and health at the
heart of its response to AIDS, by concentrating on prevention, treatment and human rights
to fight stigma and discrimination and promote accountability, through a global monitoring
system to which approximately 170 countries reported with indicators on discrimination,
stigma, and community empowerment. UNAIDS also engaged in global advocacy with
other agencies, and supported countries in eliminating stigma and discrimination,
improving monitoring, laws, legal literacy and access to justice, raising the awareness of
lawmakers, and building the capacity of health-care workers to improve quality of care. Mr.
Martineau emphasized the importance of empowering communities as agents of change.
35.
Milena Osorio, of ICRC, shared information about the ICRC Mental Health and
Psychosocial Support Unit, designed to assist victims of armed conflict, violence and
disasters. ICRC interventions were implemented in 105 multidisciplinary programmes in 50
countries and provided a comprehensive package of services in a continuum of care to
eliminate stigmatization and discrimination. She specified that her unit supported victims of
torture, families with missing relatives, victims of violence and injured persons. It applied
inclusive and multidisciplinary approaches to its work with the communities and
individuals themselves in designing programmes and providing training to professionals,
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents