A/HRC/13/31
Number of cases on which the
Government has replied
0
Multiple replies on some cases
Number of cases of possible
clarification by Government (6month rule)
N/A
0
General allegation
Yes
Government response
No
Prompt intervention letter
N/A
Government response
N/A
Working Group request for a visit
N/A
Government response
N/A
General allegations
Summary of the allegations
440. Information was submitted by sources concerning obstacles reportedly encountered
in the implementation of the Declaration. This information was transmitted to the
Government after the Working Group’s eighty-seventh session.
441. According to the information received, between 2001 and 2005 the Government of
Romania was involved in a practice of renditions and secret detention. Victims of rendition
were generally held in prolonged detention in secret facilities, with no access to the ICRC,
no notification to families and no notification of their legal status and rights. There was no
oversight of the conditions of detention and the treatment of the detainees. There was also
no information about the procedures in place to decide about their detention and its
duration. This practice is believed to amount to enforced disappearance.
442. According to the information received, Romania allowed secret detention facilities
in its territory.
443. It was also reported to the Working Group that airports in Romania were used by
planes that transported victims of rendition. Those planes stopped over in those airports
during the process of transferring, taking, delivering, or returning detainees from the
rendition. It is believed that the use of these planes, without the control and scrutiny of the
Government, was essential to facilitate and implement the rendition programme. In some
cases, these planes were used to detain individuals in European territory, while in other
cases victims of enforced disappearances were transported in and out of European space.
The Government allegedly allowed these planes to land on its territory without adopting
any measure to prevent their use for secret detention and rendition.
444. According to reports received, the Government of Romania was reluctant to
investigate thoroughly allegations of enforced disappearance connected to renditions by
claiming confidentiality on national security or state secrecy. The Government reportedly
failed to undertake effective, independent and impartial investigation into the role of state
officials and the use of state territory in connection with enforced disappearance.
Reportedly, investigations and determinations of human rights complaints in cases of
rendition and secret detention were blocked by the Government. No remedies have been
provided for the victims and their families, which includes, in some cases, the
establishment of the fate and whereabouts of people who have disappeared.
445.
94
The Working Group regrets that no response was received from the Government.
GE.09-17704
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents