A/HRC/36/58
took into consideration national laws, in recognition of their contribution to development
and in accordance with universally agreed and recognized human rights as stipulated in
international human rights law.
22.
Chile highlighted that, while the new text was an improvement, it still required
national and intersectoral consultation. The comments of Chile would be in line with its
previous ones.
23.
Brazil emphasized that the negotiation of the declaration was one of many efforts
being made to draw attention to peasants. The draft declaration should not oppose or
criticize agribusiness, whose practices should also be consistent with human rights. Brazil
would contribute to the conclusion of a balanced draft declaration, consistent with
international law.
24.
Peru stated that the text should take into account the specificities of different legal
systems, in particular regarding sovereignty over natural resources, which could not be
exercised by a particular group. Peru was ready to work towards reaching the necessary
consensus on that subject and other matters with a view to finalizing the draft declaration as
soon as possible.
25.
The Russian Federation emphasized that it had supported the resolutions
establishing the working group. The practice of translating specific standards for a group,
such as indigenous peoples, to the situation of peasants should be done with great care and
the granting of additional rights should not violate the rights of others.
26.
India highlighted that the draft declaration contained multiple rights that had been
borrowed from existing treaties and conventions and that discussions on substantive rights
must focus on existing norms.
27.
Switzerland welcomed the new draft and stressed that the priority remained the
implementation of existing instruments, for example the International Treaty on Plant
Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture (art. 9, on the rights of farmers). Addressing
the needs and challenges that peasants faced could be done through an inclusive process
and respecting a human rights-based approach.
28.
Malaysia aligned itself with the statement of the Movement of Non-Aligned
Countries. The important contributions to the national economy made by peasants and
small-scale farmers were highlighted, as was the need for an environment in which they
could thrive, in a context of global competition.
29.
The Plurinational State of Bolivia stated that the declaration was necessary to
address problems like malnutrition and lack of access to seeds, among other concerns
identified in the study of the Human Rights Council Advisory Committee.
30.
Ecuador emphasized the solidity of the draft declaration, which was based on over
50 instruments, resolutions and International Labour Organization (ILO) conventions. The
protection of human rights through international instruments had been subject to constant
evolution, allowing more attention to be paid to some groups that had been overlooked.
31.
Cuba highlighted that a declaration could contribute to solving rural, environmental
and food problems and emphasized the need to recognize new rights and increase
protection of existing rights.
32.
The Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela highlighted that many studies had
emphasized the need for a declaration on the rights of peasants. Extreme poverty, the
primitive nature of agricultural techniques and contemporary forms of slavery, among
others, pointed towards the need to support the drafting of an instrument on that subject.
The principles of the Charter of the United Nations must be reflected in the draft
declaration.
33.
Uruguay emphasized that the draft declaration was not a case of creating new rights
but of making sure that people working in rural areas could enjoy all human rights on an
equal footing.
34.
Kenya supported the draft declaration because its objectives were part of the many
solutions needed in the complicated realm of agriculture. The declaration would address the
4
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents