A/HRC/37/29
were vulnerable to exploitation by others. Many Governments allowed private
developments on indigenous lands without the consent of the peoples concerned. Land
dispossession, eviction and natural resource exploitation often threatened indigenous
cultural practices. She called on States to harmonize domestic law and practice with the
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Ms. Carpenter also
condemned the extraction and transfer of indigenous peoples’ human remains and religious
objects to institutions in other parts of the world.
62.
The author of a written submission noted that for development to be undertaken in
an environmentally and culturally sustainable way and without posing a threat to cultural
heritage, planning processes must be informed and controlled through appropriate
legislation and through transparent and public assignment of the roles and responsibilities
of all stakeholders.
63.
A participant recalled the work of the open-ended intergovernmental working group
on a draft United Nations declaration on the rights of peasants and other people working in
rural areas, and pointed to a draft article on “cultural rights and traditional knowledge”.
Peasants and persons working in rural areas had the right to enjoy their culture and to
preserve, protect and develop their traditional knowledge as a way of life. Mr. Mancisidor
noted that the draft declaration could provide opportunities to advance the right to free,
prior and informed consent of peasants and indigenous peoples in the management of,
enjoyment of and participation in heritage.
C.
National experiences
64.
The representative of Armenia indicated that the destruction of cultural masterpieces
was an attempt to erase memory and destroy cultures and civilizations, and recalled the
destruction of the Mosul museum, the Bamiyan Buddha, the mausoleums of Timbuktu and
the thousands of medieval Armenian cross stones in Nakhijevan. Such manifestations of
intolerance and extremism should be strongly condemned and punished.
65.
The representative of the Technical Committee on Cultural Heritage in Cyprus
reported that the Committee had been established to protect the cultural heritage that is
valued by both communities living in Cyprus. It provided a bicommunal platform for
cooperation and dialogue which defied the north-south divide. The Committee could be
seen as an emerging model of how two communities had come to appreciate their common
interest in their cultural heritage in a way that could inspire actors in areas where tensions
persisted.
66.
The representative of RASHID International commended the Iraqi and other armed
forces active in Iraq for having consulted about heritage sites to be avoided as targets. It
encouraged Iraq’s efforts to re-establish a system of centrally paid site guards and to
establish a national Blue Shield committee. He urged the coordination of international
efforts to assist Iraq following the liberation of territory from Daesh to survey and digitally
document cultural heritage, collect evidence for possible prosecution and provide
conservation aid. The United Nations, including UNESCO and OHCHR, should lead those
efforts. He further stressed the need for a thorough review of school curricula in Iraq to
strengthen cross-cultural understanding and engagement, and urged the international
community to provide capacity-building and training.
67.
In a written submission concerning the situation in the Syrian Arab Republic, it was
noted that often monuments that appear to be “minor” in the eyes of outsiders acted as the
glue that kept a community together. The emotional and spiritual attachment to such sites,
especially for people forcibly displaced and wishing to return, had often been overlooked
when discussing the protection of cultural heritage. It was stressed that while the world
would rightly mourn the destruction of Palmyra, the destruction of countless other
monuments of great significance to Syrians must not be forgotten and must be included in
criminal charges.
10
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents