A/HRC/29/41
dwelling unit, with building permits obtained illegally or without the necessary building
permit, or that the land had been reassigned, which had rendered the individual’s use
illegal.
50.
In many instances, the homes had been built over many years and had cost the entire
life savings of those who had invested in them on the assumption that matters would be
formalized at a later point, for example, after the payment of fines imposed by the relevant
authorities, given that authorities had delivered only a few building permits since 2006.
Even in situations where renovations were undertaken due to wear and tear, residents faced
problems, as pointed out by one interlocutor:28
If part of an old building needs to be renovated or to be fixed, they consider that you
are building afresh and punish you as if you are building a new house. If they think
you have built without permission, you don’t get any warning, your house gets
marked with a sign and they send military personnel to destroy your house without
any warning. They also can also ask you to demolish your own house and if you
don’t they do it themselves and ask you to pay for the cost of demolition.
1.
Forced evictions and their impact
51.
The Special Rapporteur has received information concerning recent demolitions of
approximately 800 houses in Asmara, in several other villages in the vicinity of Asmara and
in other towns, such as Adi Keyh, in the southern part of the country. About 3,000 people
were made homeless owing to the forced evictions and demolitions.29 With relatives and
friends giving refuge to those evicted, an already serious problem of overcrowded housing
with limited access to affordable water and safe sanitation has been exacerbated. Many of
those evicted have gone back to their villages or to the outskirts of their towns, in the hope
of being able to afford shelter.
52.
Residents protested that the evictions had been carried out without appropriate and
adequate notice. After threatening to demolish the dwellings, the authorities simply moved
in and residents were left in a state of fear as officials marked their houses with crosses
before pulling the structures down. Military personnel carried out the evictions with heavy
equipment (bulldozers and other construction equipment), engaging in egregious brutality
and violence against anyone who stood in the way of the demolition, thus forcing many of
those affected to become bystanders as their homes were demolished.
53.
In the case of Adi Keyh, town residents opposed the demolition and eviction plan
fiercely, leading to physical confrontations between high-school children and the military.
The Special Rapporteur received reports that at least two people who stood in the way of
the military to save their homes were allegedly killed on 5 March 2015.30 A dozen high
school students were taken into custody when they tried to stop the demolitions and
because of their participation in the protests. In other cases, residents were forced to
scramble to protect their few possessions as the bulldozers relentlessly crushed everything
in their path. There is little evidence that the State authorities took any proactive measures
to inform those facing eviction of the demolitions. The impact has been greater on more
vulnerable groups of society, including women, children and the elderly.
28
29
30
14
Ibid.
The figures represent conservative estimates collated from different sources provided by human rights
defenders, as the authorities have not made any official statistics available regarding the number of
houses torn down, the number of people displaced, the number of people injured and the number of
those who lost their lives during the evictions.
There are conflicting reports regarding the number of people who were killed or injured in the process
of demolition by the military. The authorities have not published any official statistics.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents