A/HRC/7/4 page 7 Opinion No. 9/2007 Country Saudi Arabia 10/2007 Lebanon 11/2007 Government’s reply No Person(s) concerned Opinion Messrs. Hussain Khaled Albuluwy, Abdullah b. Slimane Al Sabih, Sultan b. Slimane Al Sabih, Salah Hamid Amr Al Saidi, Ahmed Abdo Ali Gubran, Manna Mohamed Al Ahmed Al Ghamidi and Jasser b. Mohamed Al Khanfari Al Qahtani Detention arbitrary, category I. Yes Mr. Youssef Mahmoud Chaabane Detention arbitrary, category III. Afghanistan and United States of America No Mr. Amine Mohammad Al Bakry Detention arbitrary, category I. 12/2007 Ecuador Yes Mr. Antonio José Garcés Loor Detention not arbitrary. 13/2007 Viet Nam Yes Dr. Pham Hong Son Between 27 March 2002 and 30 August 2006: Detention arbitrary, categories II and III. 14/2007 United Kingdom Yes Mr. Abdesslam Mahdi Case filed (paragraph 17 (a) of the Working Group’s methods of work - person released). 15/2007 Central African Republic No Mr. Bertrand Namour Detention arbitrary, category I. 16/2007 Libyan Arab Jamahiriya No Mr. Mohamed Hassan Aboussedra Detention arbitrary, category I. 17/2007 United States of America Yes Mr. Ahmed Mohamed Barodi Case filed (paragraph 17 (a) of the Working Group’s methods of work - person deported to third country). 18/2007 Jordan Yes Mr. Issam Mohamed Tahar Al Barqaoui Al Uteibi Detention arbitrary, category II. 19/2007 Saudi Arabia Yes Mr. Zhiya Kassem Khammam Al Hussain Detention arbitrary, category I. 20/2007 Mexico Yes Messrs. Jorge Marcial Zompaxtle Tecpile, Gerardo Zompaxtle Tecpile and Gustavo Robles López Detention arbitrary, category III. 21/2007 Egypt Yes Mr. Yasser Essayed Chaabane Al Dib and 18 other persons Detention arbitrary, category I and II. 22/2007 Egypt Yes Mr. Abdeldjouad Mahmoud Ameur Al Abadi Detention arbitrary, category I and III. 23/2007 Eritrea Yes Mr. Petros Solomon and 10 more persons Detention arbitrary, category I and II. 24/2007 Egypt Yes Mr. Mustapha Hamed Ahmed Chamia Detention arbitrary, category I and II.