A/HRC/18/32
C. Encouraging States to adopt national legislation on private
military and security companies
73.
Although an international regulatory framework is to be developed over the next few
years, national measures will be critical to ensure effective regulation of private military
and security companies. This is envisaged in the draft convention, which provides that
States parties should establish a comprehensive domestic regime of regulation and
oversight over the activities in its territory of private military and security companies and
their personnel, including all foreign personnel, in order to prohibit and investigate illegal
activities as defined by the convention and by relevant national laws.
74.
Very few States have adopted national legislation on private military and security
companies; some States have even excluded the possibility of adoption of national
legislation and favoured self-regulation by the industry instead. For instance, the
Government of the United Kingdom announced in Parliament in March 2011 that it would
seek to establish a code of conduct setting out national standards derived from the
International Code of Conduct, and to monitor and audit compliance of private military and
security companies based in the United Kingdom. However, the Government does not
consider it necessary to pass legislation to regulate private military and security companies.
75.
While there is currently no specific international requirement that States should
adopt national legislation on private military and security companies, the Working Group
recommends that States adopt such legislation, particularly when they are contracting
States, States on whose territory such companies operate or States on whose territory these
companies are established. It recalls that States have international legal obligations relating
to private military and security companies and that the most effective way for States to
implement such obligations is through the adoption of legislation.
76.
Drawing from the experience of its many country visits, the Working Group reached
the conclusion that it is only through comprehensive national legislation that States can
ensure adequate monitoring and oversight over the activities of private military and security
companies. Such legislation should address such specific issues as vetting of companies and
employees, licensing, training requirements, regular reporting and monitoring, regular
audits and/or inspections, complaints mechanisms and so on.
77.
The adoption of national legislation is of course only a first step towards the
establishment of a comprehensive domestic regime of regulation and oversight over the
activities of private military and security companies. Even where States have adopted
specific legislation to address the phenomenon of private military and security companies,
they have encountered challenges in the implementation of such legislation. As is discussed
below, prosecutions under the legislation have proved especially difficult for a variety of
reasons.
D. Holding private military and security companies accountable for
human rights violations
78.
The purpose of efforts to develop an international regulatory framework for private
military and security companies and national regimes of regulation is ultimately to prevent
human rights violations and ensure the accountability of the companies and individuals
involved in such violations when they occur. The Working Group has noted, however, that
prosecutions of these companies and their employees remain rare. Prosecutions have
proved difficult for a variety of reasons, such as jurisdictional issues when the company
was operating as part of, or in the context of, the military forces deployed to a country, lack
of detailed and consistent reporting of incidents involving the companies, and difficulties in
the collection of evidence, compounded by the fact that incidents often occur in conflict
areas. In States where private military and security companies are operating, issues such as
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents