A/HRC/35/37
company or the “silo” of a single supply chain towards sector-wide or market
transformation to ensure that sustainability standards, including respect for human rights,
are the norm in business. However, the role of such initiatives in sector transformation and
their impact on national legal frameworks to promote labour and human rights has been
challenged.
49.
The above issues, along with the absence of good practices related to remedy for
aggrieved workers, were raised throughout the consultation with multi-stakeholder
initiatives and industry coalitions as areas for further engagement across supply chain
initiatives.
D.
Engaging with multi-stakeholder initiatives and auditing companies
50.
The Special Rapporteur deemed it essential to engage with multi-stakeholder
initiatives, industry coalitions and representatives of the auditing industry in order to
discuss how they address challenges and criticisms, and, through constructive dialogue, to
identify areas on which further efforts should be focused. In particular, the consultations
and subsequent follow-up activities provided opportunities to enhance learning about the
risks of human trafficking in supply chains, consider the strengths and weaknesses of
strategies to detect and remedy trafficking in persons, identify challenges and share good
practices in auditing and assessments, explore current trends in the professionalization of
the auditing industry, and explore synergies between participating organizations, the
Special Rapporteur, governments and civil society.
51.
The two consultations revealed that multi-stakeholder initiatives, industry coalitions
and the auditing community were greatly interested in collaborating with the Special
Rapporteur, recognizing the instrumental role that the Special Rapporteur can play in
creating a space for open and ongoing dialogue and exchanges on lessons learned and good
practices. As no other platform having the same level of credibility and independence as
that of the Special Rapporteur exists, representatives of multi-stakeholder initiatives and
auditing companies welcomed and encouraged the continuation of the initiatives led by the
mandate holder with a view to identifying good practices that can be replicated in other
contexts and exploring innovative responses to common challenges.
52.
Regarding lessons learned and challenges in detecting cases of forced labour and
trafficking in persons, representatives of the auditing community were asked to consider the
strengths and weaknesses of current audit strategies, including how auditors addressed
recruitment and migration practices, how they gathered information from workers, and
challenges and constraints related to client expectations.
53.
It was noted that, while social audits had contributed positively to establishing a
baseline understanding of human rights and labour conditions in the workplace, other forms
of engagement, including training and capacity-building for compliance staff and the
development and dissemination of targeted guidance on human trafficking, were equally
important. Other types of assessments were also highlighted, including self-assessments
carried out by suppliers to evaluate their own compliance with standards and assessments of
labour supply chains to review conditions of recruitment and migration, where those
conditions pose risks of, inter alia, debt bondage and forced labour for migrant workers.
54.
The consultations also fostered robust dialogue on strategies and engagement aimed
at promoting workers’ voices and empowerment within sustainability initiatives, especially
within compliance monitoring schemes, including complaints hotlines, the use of worker
surveys, good practices in engaging workers during audits, training and capacity-building
for workers on their rights and responsibilities in the workplace, and training on workermanagement dialogue in the workplace. However, ensuring that potentially vulnerable
workers, such as migrants, young people and women, were not inadvertently excluded from
these new strategies was identified as a challenge.
55.
Other proposed strategies to strengthen audits, improve measures to detect and
provide remedy in trafficking cases, and better implement complementary efforts alongside
assessments included increasing community and stakeholder engagement, improving
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents