A/HRC/11/32
page 9
World Bank Special Representative to the United Nations and the World Trade Organization,
further stated that monitoring and accountability cannot be achieved without an explicit
reference to the principle of progressive realization, which is currently missing in the draft
guiding principles.
21. The Governments of Argentina and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, and the
National Consultative Commission on Human Rights (France) remarked that extreme poverty is
a violation of basic rights and a leading factor in aggravating discrimination. The Government of
Mexico, however, was of the view that extreme poverty is a violation of human dignity, while
the Government of Finland stated that poverty as such is not a human rights violation but the
causes and consequences of extreme poverty often constitute violations of various human rights.
At the seminar, the independent expert on human rights and extreme poverty remarked that the
issue of whether poverty constitutes in itself a violation of human rights is not an easy question
and suggested that the draft guiding principles should stress instead how human rights are
applicable to people living in extreme poverty.
22. The independent expert on human rights and extreme poverty suggested that
non-discrimination should also be developed in paragraph 3, thereby grounding and rendering
consistent the references provided elsewhere in the draft guiding principles, and situating
non-discrimination as an overarching element. The Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions
noted that this process constitutes a unique opportunity to unequivocally recognize poverty as a
ground of discrimination, thereby enriching the international law acquis in this area.
23. The Government of Switzerland and Zdzislaw Kedzia suggested that the universal periodic
review be mentioned in paragraph 5.
24. Joseph Ingram suggested incorporating the recommendation that country economic and
sector analyses conducted by the Government and/or donor institutions (e.g., the international
financial institutions) explicitly identify the poorest and the most marginalized, and that national
development or poverty reduction strategies address the needs of the poorest as a priority.
B. Section 1
Participation by the poor
25. Many respondents14 and seminar participants15 stressed generally that the subsection on
participation by the poor should make more explicit references to the participation of specific
groups, including indigenous and tribal peoples, minority groups, persons with disabilities, older
persons, migrants, women and girls, etc.
14
The Special Rapporteur on indigenous people, the Government of Costa Rica and the 2008
NGO Consultation.
15
The Government of Ecuador and the statement read on behalf of the independent expert on
minority issues.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents