A/HRC/13/32
42.
But refugees from hunger are not migrants. They do not move voluntarily, but out of
a state of necessity (A/62/289). They are forced to flee. Especially when famine strikes a
whole country or a whole region (for example the 2005 famine in the Sahel zone of subSaharan Africa), refugees from hunger have no other choice but to flee across international
borders. Hunger is an immediate threat to their lives and those of their families. They
should therefore be protected, not rejected. The need to strengthen protection for people
forced to leave their homes and land because of hunger was recognized by the General
Assembly in its resolution 62/164 on the right to food.
G.
Other vulnerable groups
1.
Indigenous people
43.
Indigenous people face exclusion and discrimination that have an impact on their
right to food. In Guatemala for instance, while half of all Guatemala children under the age
of 5 are stunted, malnutrition is much higher among indigenous children, with 70 per cent
stunted in their growth compared to 36 per cent of non-indigenous children
(E/CN.4/2006/44/Add.1).
44.
The right to food of indigenous people often depends closely on their access to and
control over their lands and other natural resources in their territories. The fact that their
right to food is so frequently denied and is so much related to their traditional way of living
explain why a number of indigenous organizations have expressed their deep concerns over
the obstacles and challenges that their communities face in fully enjoying this right. As
stated in the Declaration of Atitlán, at the First Indigenous Peoples’ Global Consultation on
the Right to Food in April 2002, in Guatemala:
The denial of the right to food for indigenous peoples not only denies our physical
survival, but also denies us our social organization, our cultures, traditions,
languages, spirituality, sovereignty, and total identity; it is a denial of our collective
indigenous existence.
2.
Minorities
45.
Hunger and malnutrition are largely explained by unequal power relations that
systematically disadvantage minorities. As Sylvie Brunel has noted:
From the beginning of time, in the history of humankind, minorities (political, ethnic
or religious) have always been the first to suffer from hunger, in the same way that
all populations, victims of a status considered inferior, find themselves placed on the
bottom rung of the social ladder.26
III.
Anti-discriminatory policies and strategies
A.
The question of land and agrarian reform
46.
To realize fully the right to food, more attention needs to be paid to agrarian reform
that benefits landless peasants and small-scale land holders and promotes security of tenure
and access to land. While the “death” of agrarian reform was proclaimed in the 1970s, and
few efforts were made to conduct land reform programmes in the 1980s and early 1990s,
26
12
S. Brunel, “La Faim dans le monde ; comprendre pour agir”, 1999, p. 11.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents