A/HRC/42/CRP.1
information on Houthi violations, expressed almost unanimously their fear of reprisals
when contacted by Group of Experts. Individuals appeared to have been detained simply
for expressing reservations about Houthi policies878 or posting material on social media that
criticized the Houthis.879 Additionally, media organizations continued to face restrictions
and harassment by the Houthis when covering the conflict. Furthermore, human rights
defenders, including prominent NGOs and UN representatives were obstructed and even
arrested for doing their work. For protection reasons, the Group of Experts will not provide
details on the cases it investigated.
(b) Yemeni armed forces and affiliated UAE-backed armed groups
578. During 2018 and through 2019, the Yemeni armed forces and affiliated UAE-backed
armed groups also took measures to ensure that press coverage of the conflict was minimal
by harassing media representatives and obstructing their access to the area. 880 For example,
a TV Network based in Aden reported severe restrictions in any area under the control of
UAE-backed forces in the Western Coast. The TV station was prevented from covering the
battle of al-Hudaydah by the Security Belt when it attempted to deploy Aden-based staff to
the western coast. Its staff were told to leave or face arrest and detention. 881
(c)
Violations
579. On the basis of the evidence collected and reviewed, the Group of Experts finds
reasonable grounds to believe that the de facto authorities and the Government of Yemen
are responsible, in al-Hudaydah, for severe restrictions on freedom of expression in
violation of their human rights obligations applicable to the territory under their control.
Freedom of expression may be restricted, but only as provided by the law and as necessary
for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others, as well as for the protection of
national security, public safety, order, health or morals.882 These conditions do not appear
to have been fulfilled in the cases examined by the Group of Experts.
5.
Arbitrary detention, enforced disappearances, torture, and ill-treatment
(a) De facto authorities
580. The Group of Experts investigated 17 cases 883 of detention by the de facto
authorities in the context of the fighting in the al-Hudaydah governorate. In addition, the
Group followed up on previously received information on disappearances and torture
carried out by the de facto authorities in the governorate. 884
581. The detention situation in the governorate during the fighting followed general
patterns previously documented in de facto authority detention facilities in al-Hudaydah
and in other parts of the country. The situation was worsened by a sense of chaos related to
the detainees’ transfer out of and within al-Hudaydah during the fighting and by the
increasingly arbitrary reasons for detention, which seemed to be related to efforts by the
Houthis to tighten their grip on the civilian population during the conflict.
878
Confidential Sources on File.
Confidential Sources on File.
880 The coalition continues to impede the work of international media and human rights organizations.
Since at least early 2017, the coalition, which clears United Nations flight manifests into Yemen, has
not allowed human rights organisations or media to fly on UN flights, implementing a rule that
UNHAS flights are only for UN staff and humanitarian organisations. Consequently, human rights
INGOs and international journalists only have the option to take commercial flights to governmentcontrolled areas and then travel by car to other parts of Yemen, including those under the control of
the Houthis. Given the insecure nature of the roads, this measure by the coalition impedes meaningful
international monitoring of the situation in Yemen.
881 Confidential Source on File.
882 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, arts. 19; see also Human Rights Committee
general comment No. 34, paras. 21–36.
883 Confidential Sources on File.
884 Confidential Sources on File.
879
140
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents