A/HRC/42/49
ruling party, which could feel threatened by the popularity of the Congrès national pour la
liberté, could be experiencing a crisis of confidence. The history of Burundi shows that
CNDD-FDD turns to violent strategies when it faces organized opposition, particularly in
elections. In addition, the ruling party and State institutions are becoming increasingly
difficult to tell apart.
69.
There have also been excesses in the exercise of power by the Head of State. The
Head of State has extensive powers under the Constitution, but he does not hesitate to make
decisions that are not his prerogative, such as the appointment of the executive officers of
the National Communication Council. In addition, he continues to rely on shadowy
informal structures, such as the “committee of generals”.31 He also uses the National
Security Council, which he chairs, to govern directly.32 For example, although the Council
has no decision-making authority, it decided to suspend the activities of foreign NGOs in
October 2018. Having the National Intelligence Service report directly to the Office of the
President is another significant example of his concentration of power in his hands. The
ease with which the President bypasses institutions reveals their weakness.
70.
The theme of the divine origin of the President’s power is increasingly common in
official speeches delivered by the President and his wife. A slide into religiosity is also
apparent in some of the Head of State’s decisions, in particular his plan to reform society
and help it recover its “true values”. His frequent references to the Burundian monarchy
and the decision to place the royal motto “God, King, Country” back on public monuments
are leading to speculation by analysts and some Burundians about a possible restoration of
the monarchy for his benefit.
71.
The culture of secrecy typical of CNDD-FDD makes it impossible to know the
status of the process for the nomination of the party’s candidate for the presidential
elections, raising the question of whether the delay is linked to possible strife in the party,
as in 2015.
72.
A new electoral code entered into force on 20 May 2019. Independent candidates are
subject to limitations on running in parliamentary elections and must obtain better results
than candidates who are members of political parties.
73.
The Independent National Electoral Commission, whose seven members are
associates of CNDD-FDD or its allied parties, is not independent of the executive
authorities or the ruling party.
3.
Misuse of history
74.
The issue of ethnicity is one of considerable historical import in Burundi. Ethnicity,
whether a colonial fabrication or a traditional social reality, often made use of, remains one
of the determinants of the identity of most Burundians. Since independence, numerous
human rights violations with an ethnic dimension have caused many Burundians to distrust
and resent the other group and generated a body of differing memories. The Head of State
delivers lecture after lecture at meetings in which he teaches the “true” history of Burundi.
The mandate of the new Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which is not independent,
is to “rewrite the history of Burundi” and investigate the crimes and violations that have
been committed since 1885.
75.
The current approaches raise concerns that the imposition of a biased official version
of the country’s history could sharpen the grievances of the past, with troubling
consequences. The lack of genuine and appropriate reconciliation and transitional justice
processes, as provided for in the Arusha Peace and Reconciliation Agreement for Burundi,
helps maintain these rifts, which some may seek to exploit for political ends.
31
32
14
A/HRC/39/CRP.1, para. 733 (document available on the Commission’s website).
The National Security Council is an advisory body established under article 275 of the Constitution to
assist the President and the Government with policy development and monitoring in respect of
security and with the formulation of defence, security and policing strategies in the event of a crisis.
GE.19-13419
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents