A/HRC/7/7
page 10
transnational corporations operate.17 An emerging trend in Latin America but also in other
regions of the world indicates situations of private security companies protecting transnational
extractive corporations whose employees are often involved in suppressing the legitimate social
protest of communities and human rights and environmental organizations of the areas where
these corporations operate. Furthermore, in exchange for providing security services to some
African Governments, PMSCs have in some cases received concessions for the exploitation of
natural resources.18
27. PMSCs are at present rarely held accountable by effective oversight mechanisms at
parliamentary levels, whether in the States that contracts them or in the countries where they
operate. It also appears that PMSCs determine and influence the demand for security services.
As regards their involvement in institution-building in post-conflict situations their services raise
questions regarding sustainability and their actual contribution in ending low-intensity conflicts.
Outsourcing military and security functions has an inherent danger in ensuring State control over
the use of force.19
28. The distinction between humanitarian non-profitable organizations and corporations
working for pecuniary gain20 is also being blurred by PMSCs. In conflict or post-conflict areas,
such as Afghanistan and Iraq, where PMSCs sometimes provide security details and protection
work to humanitarian NGOs, it has become difficult for the population as well as government
officials to distinguish one from another. Humanitarian and aid-type assistance risk becoming
associated with an intervening force and PMSCs which may be perceived as biased. PMSCs
do not hesitate to utilize the aims of humanitarian non-profit organizations to advertise their
activities. One of such companies recurrently puts an ad in the Journal of International Peace
Operations (IPOA)21 in relation with its activities in Afghanistan, Somalia, Congo, Bosnia and
Herzegovina, the Sudan and Iraq displaying a picture of an individual feeding a malnourished
baby with the following message “Through selfless commitment and compassion for all people,
17
In the privatization of warfare and the utilization of private security companies to protect
multinational extractive corporations one can find elements of bygone historical periods,
the use of force by non-State actors. J.E. Thompson, Mercenaries, Pirates and Sovereigns:
State-building and Extraterritorial Violence in Early Modern Europe, Princeton University
Press, 1994. In such situations, multinational corporations contract private security companies
whose employees are often found involved in social conflicts with the local populations.
18
E/CN.4/2000/NGO/148.
19
H. Wulf, supra.
20
G. Carbonnier, ibid.
21
Publication of the International Peace Operations Association and the Peace Operations
Institute, vol. 2, No. 4, January/February 2007, Washington.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents