A/HRC/7/7
page 20
the current situation in Iraq is creating an economy based on privatized war and reconstruction
efforts.70 It is the primary responsibility of States under international and domestic law for public
security, law and order, and the Working Group emphasizes that States cannot abandon their
international responsibilities to non-State actors by outsourcing certain tasks.
E. Transnational issues
50. The Working Group noted that the provision of military and security services by
transnational companies in conflict or post-conflict situations raises important issues regarding
transparency, control of the means of violence and accountability. It poses political, legal and
human rights questions to the international community.
51. In monitoring the manifestations and emerging trends of mercenaries and
mercenary-related activities in different parts of the world as well as the effects of the
activities of PMSCs on the enjoyment of human rights, the Working Group has identified
transnational issues relating to:
− The status of the international private security guards in war zones. Former
military personnel and policemen from all parts of the world are recruited to provide
“passive or static security” in Afghanistan and Iraq. They are trained and equipped
militarily. Attacked by the insurgency, they find themselves in low-intensity conflicts
without a clear front line,71 where it is impossible to distinguish between offensive and
defensive operations. They are neither civilians nor combatants, would undermine the
Geneva Conventions by operating in a grey area, and may be easily assimilated to
mercenaries or irregular fighters;72
− Blurring the areas between non-profit humanitarian organizations and PMSCs
working for pecuniary gain. Many of the PMSCs present themselves as organizations
working for humanitarian and peace-building objectives when in fact there could be
commercial interests in prolonged conflicts;73
70
Naomi Klein, “The failure is a new face of success”, The Guardian, 12 September 2007.
71
S. Chesterman and Ch. Lehnardt, Eds., From Mercenaries to Market: The Rise and
Regulations of PMC, Oxford University Press, 2007.
72
For ICRC, a small number of PMSC employees operating in armed conflict or post-conflict
situations could be considered as combatants, some as mercenaries and the majority would be
civilians who would lose protection under international humanitarian law when taking direct part
in hostilities. See Emmanuela-Chiara Gillard, “Business goes to war: private military/security
companies and international humanitarian law”, IRRC, vol. 88, No. 863, September 2006.
73
The new low-intensity wars may last decades with no end in sight, H. Munkler, supra.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents