A/HRC/42/47
of their stalls. One study found that, as a result, all the traders interviewed suffered from
nearly constant diarrhoea.42 Equally, a lack of safe, potable water means that traders must
often either resort to using unsafe water to clean utensils and foodstuffs, or simply not use
water at all, both of which practices have the potential to contaminate food with dangerous
pathogens, thus increasing the likelihood of the vendors and their customers falling ill. 43 In
Taiwan, food traders in night markets are often not provided with potable water for
cleaning, meaning they are forced to use only paper towels to clean themselves and their
equipment, which has been identified as potentially increasing the risk of food-borne
illnesses being spread to customers.44
E.
Acceptability, privacy and dignity
51.
In the context of access to water and sanitation in public spaces, the provision of
facilities that meet the requirements of acceptability, privacy and dignity means that they
must be designed, constructed and maintained in ways that conform to the personal and
cultural needs of users. Many communities and cultures have particular and important
norms regarding sanitation practices and these can vary between and within cultures.
Accordingly, determining how to provide culturally acceptable water and sanitation
facilities in public spaces may require States to engage in meaningful consultations with
target populations regarding their requirements. Privacy and dignity should always be
ensured, in particular by considering the needs of vulnerable and marginalized users,
including women and people who are transgender, when determining the design of water
and sanitation facilities in public spaces.
52.
Failure to provide public facilities which meet the cultural needs of users and which
ensure that they are provided with privacy and dignity can minimize usage by groups who
feel unsafe as a result. This was seen in the Indian state of Telangana, where despite the city
authorities in Warangal increasing the number of public toilets and bathing facilities
available to women, actual use was considerably lower than expected. As a result, the
authorities interviewed 197 local women, including 21 from diverse backgrounds,
regarding their opinions of the facilities, their specific needs and their preferences. Many of
the women found the facilities to be inappropriately located, had men in or around the
entrances, causing distress, or had male caretakers. The interviews determined that women
wanted features such as women-only blocks, access from main thoroughfares and a choice
between squat and seat toilets. These conclusions were used to design and construct new
facilities that were specific to the needs of the women in the area. 45
V. Interlinkages with other human rights
53.
The well-acknowledged indivisibility, interdependence and interrelatedness of
human rights are strongly demonstrated in the context of access to water and sanitation in
public spaces. Where the rights to water and sanitation are not adequately respected,
protected and fulfilled within public spaces, significant negative impacts on the enjoyment
of other rights can be seen.46
42
43
44
45
46
14
See Laura Alfers, “Occupational health and safety for market and street traders in Accra and
Takoradi, Ghana” (December 2009).
See Sally Roever, “Informal economy monitoring study sector report: street vendors” (April 2014);
and Sohel Ahmed and others, “Cooking up a storm: community-led mapping and advocacy with food
vendors in Nairobi’s informal settlements”.
Yi-Mei Sun, Shu-Tai Wang and Kuo-Wei Huang, “Hygiene knowledge and practices of night market
food vendors in Tainan City, Taiwan”, Food Control, vol. 23, No. 1 (January 2012).
See WaterAid, “Female-friendly public and community toilets: a guide for planners and decision
makers”.
See Priscila Neves-Silva, Giselle Isabelle Martins and Léo Heller, “Human rights’ interdependence
and indivisibility: a glance over the human rights to water and sanitation”, BMC International Health
and Human Rights, vol. 19 (2019).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents