A/HRC/28/36
after civil wars, dictatorships or decolonization processes, have produced parallel
interpretations that have resulted in parallel realities for people, thus preventing
reconciliation.
13.
Ms. Stojanovic stated that, although it was almost impossible for two States that
were once at war with each other to develop a common narrative of past events, the
publication of a Franco-German history textbook provided a successful example of an
attempt to do just that. She specified, however, that this success was in large part due to
fortunate and rare circumstances, namely, the role of the European Union as a political
umbrella for the discussion and the highly developed state of historical and social sciences
in France and Germany.
14.
However, alternatives to developing a common narrative could be recommended,
such as adopting a multi-perspective approach that enabled all voices to be heard.
Ms. Stojanovic explained that, as a result of this methodology, four books had been
published on controversial issues relating to the wars that took place in the 1990s in the
former Yugoslavia, and that Serbia had started a project involving sixty historians with the
aim of writing a book on that part of history. Ms. Stojanovic stressed the particularly
interesting role that multiple perspectives could play in turning a controversy into a debate
in which all sides could express their interpretation. She underlined the importance of
changing the way that history as a subject was taught in schools, from hiding controversies
to showing them and opening discussion about the various existing narratives. She
recognized that, while it was often impossible to reach a consensus on past events, a
fundamental first step was for pupils to be informed about other groups’ perspectives.
15.
Ms. Stojanovic noted that history curricula tended to deal solely with political
history, which overstressed conflicts, whereas there would be large scope for learning
important historical events within social history, for example, including gender-related
history.
16.
Mr. Adwan co-authored “Side by Side: Parallel Histories of Israel-Palestine”, a
history textbook written by a group of Israeli and Palestinian teachers. He specified that the
publication of the book, the result of seven years of rigorous collaboration, followed the
failure by both sides to implement certain terms of the 1993 Oslo Accords relating to the
review of the education systems to make them peace-oriented, which had directed both
sides to develop a history textbook in the spirit of the Accords. Instead, each side continued
to teach its own narrative only. The aim of the history textbook elaborated by Mr. Adwan
and his counterparts was to introduce both narratives side by side, giving them equal space.
This became possible by choosing to present the textbook in the form of columns, one for
each narrative, with an empty space between them for students to write their comments.
Mr. Adwan stated that it not only created a sense of equality in terms of the space allocated
to each narrative, but also brought a certain symmetry between the teachers despite the
existing asymmetry of power between the two States.
17.
The main effect of the textbook was to provide Israeli and Palestinian pupils with an
opportunity to study each other’s history as well as their own. Mr. Adwan noted that, in
doing so, the project fitted into a democratic framework by, inter alia, integrating the right
of children to gain access to information and the academic freedoms of teachers and
researchers. He expressed the need to move education from being a means of perpetuating
the conflict to a means of building peace and stressed that there was scope to learn from
each other’s trauma.
18.
Mr. Adwan elaborated on some of the difficulties that he and other teachers had
encountered during the development and implementation of the project and the challenges
that lay ahead. In the developing phases of the project, the ongoing nature of the IsraeliPalestinian conflict made the collaborative process harder than expected, including in terms
5
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents