A/HRC/9/23
page 18
in their import policies, to discriminate in favour of countries whose production of agrofuels
complies with the guidelines, while excluding imports from other, non-compliant States. For
reasons of legal certainty, a waiver may be sought from the General Council of the World Trade
Organization, in order to ensure the compatibility of such a scheme with the non-discrimination
principles of articles I, XI and XIII of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade.
33. As a second element of a new international consensus on agrofuels, a permanent forum
should be established at the international level, in order to both ensure the impartial and
objective monitoring of compliance with the guidelines and constitute a platform for the
exchange of best practices in their implementation. Such a forum should have sufficient
expertise in the human rights issues raised by the production of agrofuels. It should also have the
resources to evaluate the potential impact of certain investment decisions on the prices of food
commodities, both at the international and the national levels and thus to provide assessments
guiding States in the implementation of the guidelines.
34. Consideration should also be given to the possibility of allocating quotas to countries for
the production of agrofuels. Such an allocation should take into account the energy balance of
each form of production and the impact on the price of agricultural commodities on international
markets. But it should also include consideration of the risks of distorted development in
producing countries, working in favour of crop-growers producing feed for fuel but at the same
time threatening the access to land and water of other producers, particularly small-holders
producing crops for domestic consumption, and inflating the prices of food on local markets.
B. The obligation to protect the right to adequate food
by controlling private actors
35. There exists an obligation of all States to protect the right to food effectively by regulating
the activities of companies at all levels of the system of production and distribution of food,
consistent with article 11 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural
Rights37 and with the FAO Right to food Guidelines.38 The Human Rights Council has requested
private actors “to take fully into account the need to promote the effective realization of the right
to food for all”.39 But, as noted by the Special Representative of the Secretary-General on the
issue of human rights and transnational corporations and other business enterprises in his most
recent report to the Council, the role of States in ensuring that they comply with their human
rights obligations remains crucial.40
37
General comment No. 12, para. 19 (referring to the failure by States to regulate activities of
individuals or groups so as to prevent them from violating the right to food of others as an
instance of the violation of the right to food).
38
See para. 4.3. of the Guidelines.
39
See Human Rights Council Resolution 7/1, 27 March 2008, para. 13.
40
See A/HRC/8/5 (7 April 2008), paras. 27-50.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents