A/HRC/41/39/Add.4
representatives of the people. The Special Rapporteur should not use any manipulative
information provided by NGOs in this report.
12.
Under the subheading “Social and environmental impacts” para 2
Contract Farming, in general, has benefited a large number of farmers as they can find
markets for their products to generate cash and thus reduce their poverty. There have been
few cases where orders have been issued to shut down a number of contract farming
projects due to the toxin exposure problems in the previous year. The government has
assigned relevant agencies to re-assess such plantations and bringing contractors to answer
before the law.
13.
Under the subheading “Failure to link growth with poverty reduction”
para 2
These examples are taken out of contexts, having read the full articles with explanations as
to the reasons for these early results and their potential results in the future. It is not fair to
simply quote and show only the damaging phrases while distorting from the full contexts.
As for the figures, please double-check for more correct ones as they do not seem to match
the official figure as provided by Ministry of Energy and Mining. Please consider adding
more information or remove it altogether.
14.
Under the heading “4. The Xe Pian Xe Namnoy Dam and the future of
hydropower” para 1
The Special Rapporteur had received information from the agencies concerned regarding
their plans for immediate and long-term remedy and reparation for the affected people. The
lack of awareness of those plans by some of the affected people could be due to ineffective
communication. Please consider rephrasing/changing the word “Limbo”.
15.
Under the heading “4. The Xe Pian Xe Namnoy Dam and the future of
hydropower” para 2
This paragraph has some true and untrue information, therefore it is suggested that the
Special Rapporteur revise this paragraph in a more constructive and correct way. In reality,
the central Government and the local authorities of Attapeu and Sanamxay have been trying
their utmost to help the affected people, to restore the affected areas so that the people’s
livelihood returns to normalcy. Of course, in this process the affected people may not be
happy with the temporary house and the assistance but it is the best effort by the authorities
to help them.
The Special Rapporteur mentioned one person describing the condition as “torturous” this
is a view of one person among thousands affected, therefore should not be used as reference
representing the view of a larger group of affected people.
16.
Under the heading “4. The Xe Pian Xe Namnoy Dam and the future of
hydropower” para 3
This is just some comments of a few people who might have misunderstood or have not
been aware at all of the plans and policies of the government, these comments could not
reflect the situation as a whole and not appropriate to put in the report. So we propose to
remove these sentences.
4
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents