A/HRC/10/59
page 17
60. The Government has cooperated with the International Criminal Court on a number of
cases. However, operating on their own without international involvement, Congolese authorities
often prove reluctant to investigate and prosecute military, law enforcement and intelligence
personnel who perpetrate or bear command responsibility for serious human rights violations.26
61. Political interference at all stages of the criminal process is very common. There have also
been numerous incidents, especially in the east of the DRC, in which military and civilian judges
and prosecutors were threatened and attacked by armed group members and sometimes even
members of the armed force to intimidate them, disrupt criminal proceedings and ensure
impunity. Extremely low salaries in the justice, law enforcement and penitentiary sectors also
provide numerous entry points for corruption at all levels. The special procedures welcome that
the President of the Republic, in his second address on the state of the nation of 14 December
2008 acknowledged the problem of interference in the judicial process and emphasized that such
interference must not happen and violators will be pursued.
62. The impunity problem is also rooted in the capacity of the justice system. Deprived of an
adequate budget, the justice system remains in a deplorable state and lacks the capacity to handle
its caseload. The access of the population to justice is extremely limited, not only because of
high rates of poverty, but also by the utterly insufficient number of judges, magistrates and
tribunals and their lack of geographic coverage in the East and remote areas generally. In
January 2008, the Ministry of Justice put forward a Plan of Action for Justice Reform in the
DRC, focusing among other things on recruitment, training and infrastructure. The tenets of the
Plan still needed to be approved by the Mixed Committee on Justice Reform Follow-up when
this report was finalized.
63. The disastrous state of the prison system, perhaps the weakest link in the justice chain,
facilitates escapes of suspects and convicts, including high profile offenders who sometimes
“escape” with the connivance of the authorities. For this reason, but also in light of the generally
appalling prison conditions, characterized by serious overcrowding, a lack of basic health care,
and starvation due to the virtual absence of a budget to provide to detainees without family
support, penitentiary reform is an absolute necessity.27 The implementation of a new Strategic
Plan on Prison Reform and Training, developed by the Ministry of Justice and MONUC, should
therefore be a priority for the Government and its technical assistance partners.28
64. The new Constitution, in force since 18 February 2006, sets out a good foundation to
reform the justice sector and establish the rule of law. In August 2008, the President signed a law
creating the Higher Judicial Council, which is a very important step forward. It is crucial that this
new Higher Judicial Council be actively involved in the judicial reform process and that it is
26
There are exceptions. In Goma, for instance, FARDC set up an ad hoc Operational Military
Court in November 2008. Based on quick trials with uncertain due process guarantees, the Court
had convicted 18 soldiers, 4 of whom received death sentences, when this report was finalized.
27
See A/HRC/7/6/Add.4, paras. 80-85, and A/HRC/4/7, para. 37.
28
S/2008/728, para. 38.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents