A/HRC/12/48
page 143
the entry point of the shell is easily detectable. The shell then penetrated the inner concrete wall
of the hospital where the pharmacy was located. The pharmacy was completely destroyed as a
result. An eyewitness described that, through the holes made in the corrugated iron, he observed
a tank on a road between two buildings about 400 metres eastwards. Although he could not say
whether it was this tank that had struck the hospital directly, it was in a direct line in relation to
the entry point of the shell.
606. Throughout the day the hospital was unable to procure the assistance of civil defence
forces or other fire-fighting support. As a result, the staff of the hospital were almost entirely
consumed with the task of saving the buildings and ensuring the safety of patients.
607. It was not until around 4 p.m. that it was possible to coordinate an evacuation of hospital
patients with the assistance of ICRC, which made clear upon arrival that it would be able to carry
out this procedure only once. Those not evacuated at this point were relocated to the operating
theatres of the hospital.
608. At around 8 p.m. another fire broke out causing serious damage to the main hospital
building. As a result of this fire it was decided to carry out a total evacuation of the remaining
patients as well as a number of local residents who had sought refuge in the hospital. It was at
this stage that one of the senior doctors took an eight-year-old girl who had been struck by a
bullet in the jaw and was critically ill to al-Shifa hospital, where she later died. At that point he
says he felt that there was very heavy fire in the area and that there appeared to be some attempts
to aim directly at or near to the ambulance.
609. Meanwhile, 200 metres to the east in al-Abraj Street the PRCS ambulance depot had also
been severely damaged. One of its principal buildings was entirely destroyed. The Mission also
saw the remnants of three PRCS ambulances that had been parked at the entrance to the depot.
Two had been crushed by tanks but not burned out. The other ambulance showed signs of having
been struck directly in the front below the windscreen by a missile of some description and
having been burned out.
610. The devastation caused to both the hospital buildings, including the loss of all archives in
the administrative building, and the ambulance depot was immense, as was the risk to the safety
of the patients.
611. The Mission examined a number of the shells retrieved by the hospital staff and reviewed
footage taken at the time as well as still photographs.
2.
The Israeli position
612. The Israeli authorities did not specifically mention the incident at al-Quds hospital in the
conclusions of their investigations on 22 April 2009.374
Annex B addresses some allegations regarding the use of ambulances, but not the attack on the hospital. See
http://dover.idf.il/IDF/English/Press+Releases/09/4/2202.htm.
374
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents