A/HRC/35/22
renders ineffective access to telecommunications networks, mobile services, social
media platforms and so forth. Future work of the Council that clarifies the rules that
apply to digital access, as outlined in this report, would advance the right to freedom
of opinion and expression online.
78.
It is also critical for the Council and States to draw the connections between
privacy interference and freedom of expression. To be sure, interferences with privacy
must be assessed on their own merits under article 17 of the International Covenant
on Civil and Political Rights and other norms of human rights law. But certain
interferences — such as overbroad requests for user data and third party retention of
such data — can have both near- and long-term deterrent effects on expression, and
should be avoided as a matter of law and policy. At a minimum, States should ensure
that surveillance is authorized by an independent, impartial and competent judicial
authority certifying that the request is necessary and proportionate to protect a
legitimate aim.
79.
The Special Rapporteur is particularly concerned about reports of threats and
intimidation of companies, their employees and their equipment and infrastructure.
Also, the Council’s emphasis on the important role — and need for protection — of
the private sector deserves consideration. States should review all activities to obtain
network access to ensure that they are lawful, necessary and proportionate, paying
particular attention to whether these activities are the least intrusive means for
protecting a legitimate aim.
80.
The protective role that States may exercise over the private sector can only go
so far. They should not be promoting the economic gain of private entities over users’
rights to freedom of opinion and expression. Thus, States should prohibit attempts to
assign priority to certain types of Internet content or applications over others for
payment or other commercial benefits.
81.
The intersection of State behaviour and corporate roles in the digital age
remains somewhat new for many States. One profitable way forward, at both the
international and domestic levels, would involve the development of national action
plans on business and human rights in order to establish meaningful avenues for all
categories of the digital access industry to identify and address their respective human
rights impacts.
Private actors
82.
For years now, individuals and companies within the digital access sector have
understood that they play an essential role in the vast expansion of access to
information and communications services. They are in a business in which the model
for success should involve expanding access, efficiencies, diversity and transparency.
They should take the principles identified in the present report as tools to strengthen
their own roles in advancing users’ rights to freedom of expression. In this spirit, in
addition to high-level policy commitments to human rights, the industry should
allocate appropriate resources towards the fulfilment of these commitments, including
due diligence, rights-oriented design and engineering choices, stakeholder
engagement, strategies to prevent or mitigate human rights risks, transparency and
effective remedies. In doing so, the design and implementation of corporate human
rights accountability measures should draw on both internal and external expertise,
and ensure meaningful input from customers and other affected rights holders, civil
society and the human rights community.
83.
This is not to say that private companies do not face pressures. They do. But
when States request corporate involvement in censorship or surveillance, companies
should seek to prevent or mitigate the adverse human rights impacts of their
involvement to the maximum extent allowed by law. In any event, companies should
take all necessary and lawful measures to ensure that they do not cause, contribute or
become complicit in human rights abuses. Arrangements with corporate partners
should be structured to ensure that all parties uphold their human rights
21
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents