A/HRC/15/21
205. A number of women were pushed around by soldiers, one of whom was beaten with
fists. They were also subjected to sexual taunts.
206. In a separate incident, a passenger was physically attacked by around 17 officers
when he refused to sign deportation paper, kicked in the head and threatened at gunpoint. A
number of passengers had resolved to resist deportation in order to have the opportunity to
demonstrate their innocence in an Israeli court. This was taken as a provocation by the
Israelis.
207. One medical doctor gave a detailed account of his treatment. On arrival at the
airport, the officer accompanying him jostled him and tried to trip him up on the stairs. He
was then subjected to verbal insults as he passed through a check point. An officer slapped
him on the back of the head and when he protested he was set upon by a group of
uniformed officers, knocked to the ground and repeatedly punched and kicked. He was then
dragged out of sight of other passengers where the attacks resumed. Attempts were made to
break his fingers. He was restrained with metal handcuffs behind his back so tightly that he
lost feeling to one hand. He was then hoisted up by the cuffs and pushed against a wall.
When he asked for the cuffs to be loosened, he was told this was the price he had to pay for
attempting to go to Gaza and that “it would be good for his health”. The doctor was
wearing a jacket which clearly identified him as a medical doctor and said the attacks were
completely unprovoked.
208. There were other incidents of isolated violence against individual passengers who
were deemed to be uncooperative. One passenger was seen having his arm twisted behind
his back by police to the point that the arm broke. Another was kicked and hit by some 10
soldiers, handcuffed and taken by vehicle to another place 10-15 minutes away, where
soldiers abused him for up to two hours. When he returned to the airport, he was bleeding
from the head.
209. A large number of the military and police personnel at the airport exhibited serious
and unprofessional lapses of military discipline whilst commanding officers failed in most
cases to intervene promptly. Much of the behaviour was surely criminal under domestic
Israeli law.
210. The majority of the passengers regardless of nationality were deported from Israel
aboard aircraft provided by the Government of Turkey. The Jordanian detainees however
were deported by bus across the land border between Israel and Jordan. The Greek
passengers were airlifted back to Athens aboard a Greek military aircraft sent by the
Government of Greece. At least one passenger with dual nationality, including Israeli
nationality elected not to be deported in order not to jeopardize his Israeli citizenship. He
was threatened with prosecution but was released in Israel and later left the country without
hindrance.
211. Some passengers were made to wait for many hours on board the aircraft while the
deportation procedures for the other passengers were being completed. Some passengers
said that they boarded the plane in the morning but did not take off until after midnight.
(d)
Treatment of injured passengers in Israeli hospitals
212. According to Israeli sources, 31 wounded passengers from the Mavi Marmara were
air-lifted to various hospitals in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Haifa and other locations. All
witnesses reported that there were guards, either police or soldiers or both, at the bedside or
stationed outside their rooms. They remained in the hospitals for between three and five
days receiving medical treatment and were then transferred to Turkey by aeroplane. Most
were then taken directly to the Atatürk Research Hospital in Ankara for further treatment.
44
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents