A/HRC/17/44
155. 165. Borders and crossing points were identified as a particular site of
indiscriminate shelling, including firing from the Libyan-Tunisian border towards the AlDehiba crossing point. Medical staff from Zintan reported the killing of four shepherds by
members of the Sahab Katiba. The doctor reported that most of the seriously injured
coming to the clinic where he worked in Zintan, suffered wounds from heavy weaponry
such as anti-aircraft weapons, tank shells, Katyusha and Grad missile.
156. Misrata: The Commission received a number of accounts of indiscriminate attacks
on civilians in Misrata. The exact number of civilian casualties is unconfirmed. In a
statement on 11 April, UNICEF Regional Director for the Middle East and North Africa
stated that the Fund had verified at least 20 deaths and many more injuries due to shrapnel
from mortars and tanks and bullet wounds. A senior medical doctor and an administrator of
the city‟s main hospital was quoted in the media as stating that as of 18 April, about 1,000
people had been killed and 3,000 injured, with some 80 per cent of the deaths being
civilian.121 Following an inter-agency assessment mission to Misrata on 21 and 22 May, the
World Health Organization stated that “although medical records were very much affected
during the conflict, figures collected suggest that an average of 70 people were injured and
12 killed everyday”.122 In many of the cases, while the Commission was able to establish
that many civilians (including children) have been killed or injured, the Commission was
not able to determine the full circumstances of the attacks in order to be able to evaluate
whether the attacks were intentional, indiscriminate and/or disproportionate. There were
numerous cases of shells hitting houses causing fires and persons being killed when shots
entered their cars. Many persons from Misrata reported that they had suffered injuries at
check points as a result of rounds launched by Government forces. Reports were also
received of snipers taking aim and shooting at any and all persons who left their homes near
the Bu Minyar building, which was one of the three tall buildings utilized by snipers
supporting the efforts of Government forces in Misrata.
(b)
Attacks on cultural objects and places of worship
157. In Libya, mosques are not just places of worship for Muslims, who constitute the
overwhelming majority of the population, they also have become, by default, the only
gathering place of the population that is not under full control of the authorities. During the
demonstration period, there were occasions in which authorities fired on persons as they
came out of the mosque, after Friday prayers or after religious ceremonies for those who
had died during the crisis. The Commission received credible reports, supported by
photographs, that mosques were damaged by shelling during attacks by Government forces
on inhabited areas. More investigation would be required to determine if the attacks were
intentional or incidental. Witnesses from the Nafusa Mountain told the Commission that
mosques were intentionally targeted, with particular reference made to Takut Mosque, AlBaruni Mosque in Yafran, Zintan Mosque, Kikla Mosque and Kut Mosque between March
and April 2011. Human Rights Watch stated that Government attacks hit four mosques in
Zintan as of 21 April, namely, the Al-Khalil, Ali Hdibah, Al-Aswad and Rahmah Mosques,
as well as a Ghasro Mosque in Takut. Amnesty International reported that on 17 April
rocket and mortar attacks in Misrata were ongoing and there was extensive damage to
Omar Abdel Aziz al-Senusi Mosque.123 The Commission did not receive any information
suggesting the use of mosques for military purposes. Human Rights Watch, in their report
121
122
123
44
Mail and Guardian Online, 18 April 2011.
World Health Organization, “Boosting humanitarian health support inside Libya”, May 2011.
Available from www.who.int/hac/crises/lby/highlights_may2011/en/.
Amnesty International, Libya: Misratah - under siege and under fire (London, 2011), p. 15, available
from http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/MDE19/019/2011/en.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents