A/HRC/17/44
force, cuffed and severely beaten before being killed. 171 One Chadian woman reported
having been raped by armed civilians in Benghazi on 26 February. 172
5.
Violations committed by Government forces
198. A smaller number of attacks were reported as having taken place at the hands of
Government forces. The current conflict appears to have exacerbated pre-existing
discriminatory attitudes within the society. Reports of the ill-treatment include one case of
arbitrary arrest and ill-treatment of a Nigerian national by Government forces in Misalata
(Arba Area).173 The enforced disappearance of his wife in the same incident was reported.
The incident allegedly occurred on 30 March when heavily armed Government forces
violently entered the victim‟s house, smashing him to the ground and beating him. He
reported that he was handcuffed, blindfolded and taken in a military car to a place of
detention. Another case concerned attacks by Government forces in Tripoli, including one
case of a Sudanese man having been beaten by the Katiba of Saif al-Islam when they
entered the camp of Sudanese and Egyptian workers in Tripoli. 174 One Palestinian source
from Az-Zawiyah reported ill-treatment of migrant workers following a speech by Saif alIslam Qadhafi calling them “traitors”. However, overall, it is not clear to the Commission
whether attacks by Government forces were motivated by race or by perception of political
allegiance with the opposition forces.
199. The Commission received a range of information regarding abuses suffered by subSaharan Africans at the hands of civilians without apparent affiliation to one of the parties
to the conflict in areas remaining under the control of the Government. In Tripoli, for
instance, the Commission was told an Eritrean national had been ill-treated and
subsequently denied medical treatment in the main hospital of the capital city.175 The man
reported having being attacked with arms and metal tools on 16 March by a group of
civilians in the streets of Tripoli, causing a fractured leg, aggravated by the denial of
medical care.
200. In the face of such threats posed, many sub-Saharan Africans have faced a
particularly difficult time accessing necessities of life (such as food and water).
6.
Conclusion
201. Consistent information was received by the Commission that migrant workers, in
particular those from sub-Saharan Africa, were subject to mistreatment, contrary to
international human rights law and international humanitarian law. Mistreatment took many
forms, including having their houses subject to arbitrary search, being beaten and being
subject to other cruel and inhuman treatment. The most serious attacks on migrant workers
appear to have been linked to a suspicion that such persons were “mercenaries” on the basis
of their national origin or skin colour. Attacks were most frequently undertaken by persons
associated with the opposition forces. There have also been cases of Government forces
171
172
173
174
175
The witness was able to escape, suffered from post-traumatic stress and was transferred to psychiatric
care in Marsa Matruh, Egypt. No further details on the circumstances of the report incident were
documented.
The case is addressed in paragraph 208 of the present report.
The witness mentioned having being in different detention places in Ziniti and Tripoli for seven days
and alleged ill-treatment.
In the first incident, the victim reported that he was stabbed in the right leg when he was walking in
the streets of Tripoli on 25 February 2011. In the second case, the victim alleged being beaten on 22
February 2011 by the Katiba of Saif al-Islam when they entered the camp of Sudanese and Egyptian
workers in Tripoli.
It was reported that medical care had been denied because of discrimination based on nationality.
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents