A/HRC/17/44
clothes.” One man grabbed her breasts and another punched her in the face. Others
explained that they were repeatedly beaten with punch, rifle butts and continuously told
they were going to die. They were transported into a vehicle, which stopped repeatedly at
checkpoints, each time allowing for a new group of soldiers to land a fresh punch or a rifle
butt in their backs.108
142. A three-person BBC news team was detained on 7 March at an army roadblock and
taken to a military barrack in Tripoli. They reported that they were blindfolded, beaten with
fists, knees and rifles, hooded and subjected to mock executions by members of the Libyan
army and secret police. One of the three, Chris Cobb Smith was quoted saying that the
situation inside the detention centre was horrendous, with people being handcuffed with
swelling hands and broken ribs. He stated that at one point a guy in plainclothes with a
small sub-machine gun, walked up to him, putting his gun next to his neck and pulling the
trigger twice. The bullet whisked past his ear. The soldier just laughed. The second member
of the team, Feras Killani, a correspondent of Palestinian descent, was particularly singled
out for repeated beatings and was accused of being a spy. At some point, they were all
convinced they were going to die.109
143. There have also been a significant number of disappearances of journalists reported.
The Commission drew the attention of the Government of the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya to
the cases of at least 18 journalists and other media professionals, including both Libyans
and foreigners, who went missing in Libya and whose whereabouts remains unknown. The
Commission wrote to the Libyan authorities on 26 April and 5 May, registering concerns
with regards to the cases of 18 missing journalists and requested thorough investigations of
these cases. Among the cases referred by the Commission to Libyan authorities were six
Libyan journalists, who have been missing since February. On 19 May 2011, the
Commission, in a letter to the Libyan authorities, welcomed the release of four journalists110
and urged them to look into the cases of the remaining detained journalists with a view to
releasing them. The Commission also renewed its appeal for the release on humanitarian
grounds of the two detained journalists Lotfi Ghars and Mohamed Ali Abdelrahman, with
whom the Commission met during the visit to Al-Jdaydah detention centre in Tripoli. The
Commission received guarantees by the Libyan authorities, who vowed to investigate the
cases of missing journalists and assured the Commission that they would be released before
June 2011. On 25 May 2011, the Libyan authorities informed the Commission through a
letter that Mr. Ghars had been released, but that Mr. Abdelrahman remained in detention
awaiting trial on charges including the dissemination of incorrect information. The
Commission has been disturbed by reports of the killing of one of the journalists that the
Commission inquired about, Anton Hammerl, who had been killed on 5 April at the
outskirts of Al-Brega (see paragraph 140 above).
4.
Conclusion
144. During its investigations, the Commission has established that Government forces
were responsible for attacks on journalists and other media professionals, designed
primarily to stifle coverage of the Government response to the demonstrations, the ongoing
armed conflict and/or to retaliate for perceived or feared criticisms of the regime. Media
professionals have been subject to arbitrary arrest, torture, ill-treatment, harassment,
intimidation, enforced disappearances and in some cases have been the object of targeted
108
109
110
40
Ibid.
BBC News, “Gaddafi forces detain and beat BBC Arabic team”, 10 March 2011, available from
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12695077.
Manuel Varela de Seijas (Spanish), James Foley (American), Clare Morgana Gillis (American) and
Nigel Chandler (British) were all released on 18 May by the Libyan authorities.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents