A/HRC/43/40
environment for the child. In this context, jurisdictions allowing international surrogacy
arrangements should verify that intending parents coming from abroad will be able to return
to their countries of origin with their surrogate-born child, and that legal parentage will be
recognized by the authorities of their country of origin. 43
59.
Furthermore, the Special Rapporteur has raised issues around the lack of
comprehensive information about institutional oversight of commercial actors responsible
for surrogacy practice. She also raised concerns over the possibility of abusive practices
exploiting the economic vulnerabilities of women and girls and the power imbalances with
medical professionals and the individuals requesting surrogacy arrangements.
60.
While acknowledging the lack of international consensus on how to respond to this
practice, the Special Rapporteur is concerned that the international and national regulatory
vacuum on surrogacy arrangements often leaves children vulnerable to breaches of their
fundamental rights.
C.
Root causes and risk factors of increased vulnerability
1.
Understanding the root causes and the demand factor
61.
The demand factor of the sale and sexual exploitation of children was examined in
detail by the Special Rapporteur in her report in 2016 (A/HRC/31/58), with the aim of
providing a broad strategy for the eradication of these crimes. Demand encompasses both
the individual offenders who pay for sexual services involving children and the social,
cultural, gender and institutional constructs that create an atmosphere in which the sexual
exploitation of children is ignored, tolerated or even accepted.44 Demand also sustains and
supports the profits of the transnational criminal networks, traffickers and other
intermediaries. The Optional Protocol sets out specific obligations of States to prohibit and
criminalize these crimes (arts. 1 and 3), and emphasizes the need to raise public awareness
to reduce demand. It further calls States to adopt extraterritorial jurisdiction over these
crimes in order to deal adequately with the often international nature of demand (arts. 4–7).
62.
The profile of offenders responsible for the sexual abuse of children is diverse. The
majority do not automatically have a sexual preference for children and can be classified as
situational offenders, who often resort to prostitution involving children simply because it is
available. This category of offenders may include tourists, business travellers, foreign
workers, supporters travelling in the context of major sporting events, volunteers,
government employees deployed overseas or expatriates on extended travel or residing
abroad.45
63.
The increased accessibility and availability of child sexual abuse material online
appears to normalize this crime and may encourage potential offenders and increase the
severity of abuse.46 This includes new phenomena, such as drawings and virtual
representations of non-existing children in a sexualized manner, widely available on the
Internet.
64.
With regard to preferential offenders, law enforcement experts point out that these
individuals have limited or no opportunities to seek assistance before they engage in
harmful behaviour and criminal acts, an issue that is often overlooked by States. Existing
effective prevention programmes designed to support potential offenders and prevent their
engagement in acts of abuse should be scaled up. In general, comprehensive and evidencebased research is needed to better understand the characteristics of offenders. This will
likely improve the quality and effectiveness of existing rehabilitation programmes.
65.
Ultimately, the essential feature of most offenders is their knowledge or belief that
their actions will go unpunished. Demand is also sustained by harmful social norms and
practices. It is the responsibility of States to adopt and implement effective strategies based
43
44
45
46
See the submission from Save the Children Spain.
Foundation ECPAT International, Power, Impunity and Anonymity: Understanding the Forces
Driving the Demand for Sexual Exploitation of Children (Bangkok, 2016), p. 9.
See the submission from Foundation ECPAT International.
Further information received from the UNICEF Innocenti Office of Research.
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents