A/HRC/40/CRP.1
are dressed as civilians to more effectively collect intelligence. Many military intelligence
officers are also employed in a civilian capacity while reporting intelligence gathered in the
course of their activities back to military intelligence.
Police powers of investigation, arrest, detention, search and seizure are clearly
provided for South Sudan Police Service Act (2009) and the Code of Criminal Procedure,
and the NSS’s operations and powers are set out in the National Security Service Act (2014).
However, the SPLA Act (2009), which governs the military as a whole, does not address
itself specifically to the powers and duties of the Military Intelligence Directorate, and
internal SPLA rules governing the Military Intelligence Directorate’s operations, duties and
powers are not public. The result is that there is a complete lack of transparency as to whether
any administrative safeguards are in place to protect citizens’ constitutional rights.
c) Coordination between Security Services and Across the Country
Although the NSS and the SPLA are separate entities and operate independently, the
Commission gathered evidence which indicates they also cooperate, particularly the NSS and
the SPLA Military Intelligence Directorate. Multiple detainees, particularly those being held
or transported from localities outside Juba, described being transferred between the security
agencies.
Furthermore, a significant number of detainees are transferred between detention
facilities. Indeed, many reported having been transferred between detention facilities
multiple times, making it difficult for family, friends and sometimes even those working
within the security sector searching for them to locate them. Some have been transferred to
Juba from other towns around South Sudan, including Bazia, Magwi, Malakal, Maridi,
Nassir, Pageri, Palouch, Wau, Wau Shilluk, Yambio and Yei. The Commission documented
at least seven cases in which people arrested by the NSS and SPLA Military Intelligence
were transferred to Juba from other towns by air, including commercial and military cargo
planes and military helicopters.
Other detainees are transferred between facilities within the same town, including
between those described below and others, such as police stations. While being transferred
between locations, detainees are either forced to lie down in the beds of trucks or are put in
trucks with built in holding cells referred to as “containers”. Several witnesses described
being forced to lie down in the bed of the trucks under a bench in an area ironically referred
to as “the fridge”. One detainee described:
They then forced me to lie face down underneath a bench where the soldiers were
seated within the bed of the truck. The space where I was kept was not an enclosed
space, but it was unbearably hot, and when I was put there, I burned my arm on the
metal of the truck which was scorching hot [...] I was lying face down [...] I was
terrified because I knew we were in a military vehicle, but I didn’t know where the
soldiers were taking me. I used to hear about things like this happening to other people,
but not anyone close to me.391
Another detainee indicated he had been driven around Juba in similar conditions for
four hours. Several other detainees reported being forced to wear blind-folds made of red or
dark cloth while they were being transported between facilities.
d) Involvement of Neighbouring States
There are a number of high profile cases involving the Kenyan security forces’
participation in the rendition of South Sudanese to South Sudan and to the NSS’s custody.
These include James Gatdet Dak, Marko Lokidor Lochapio, Dong Samuel Luak, and Aggrey
Izbon Idris. James Gatdet Dak was arrested in Nairobi, Kenya by Kenyan security services
on 2 November 2016, deported to Juba and handed over to the NSS who detained him until
his trial.392 The latter two were reportedly detained in Nairobi, Kenya and unlawfully
391
392
Witness 906, ERN 101769-101782, para. 15.
UNHCR, News comment by UNHCR’s Spokesperson, Cécile Pouilly, on the return of Mr James Gatdet Dak to South Sudan,
4 November 2016; Convention on the Status of Refugees of 1951 and Protocol 1967, Article 33(1)
55
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents