A/HRC/28/51
66.
A trial session scheduled for August 2014 was postponed due to the fighting in
Tripoli, and the trial resumed in October, although Saif al-Islam Qadhafi was not connected
by video-link and has not participated in trial sessions since.
67.
While all the defendants were eventually represented by defence counsel during the
trial sessions (either retained by their families or appointed by the court), the defence
counsel for Messrs. al-Senussi and Qadhafi have changed several times and Mr. Qadhafi is
no longer represented by a lawyer. Defence counsels reported difficulties in having full and
timely access to case material and in meeting their clients in private.
68.
UNSMIL/OHCHR is concerned that the trial risks falling short of basic international
standards as reflected in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The
prosecution presented its case in June 2014, in less than one hour, without calling any
witnesses. At the time of writing, the court was asking defence counsel to present their case
and was reportedly trying to curtail the number of witnesses per defendant to two or three.
UNSMIL/OHCHR has repeatedly stressed that the trial should take place in compliance
with international human rights standards, including in relation to the importance of proper
legal representation for all defendants and for unfettered access by defence counsel to case
files and their clients in confidence. If the trial continues to proceed in this way, it will not
meet international standards. It will also constitute a missed historical opportunity to
publicly disclose and scrutinize crimes committed under the former regime.
5.
Proceedings before the International Criminal Court
69.
Following the Security Council’s referral of the situation in Libya to the Prosecutor
of the International Criminal Court in 2011, the Court issued arrest warrants and requested
the transfer of Abdullah al-Senussi and Saif al-Islam Qadhafi to The Hague. The Libyan
authorities challenged the admissibility of the cases. On 21 May 2014, the Appeals
Chamber confirmed that the case of Mr. Qadhafi was admissible before the Court, in part
because it found that he was not in State custody. In contrast, in July 2014, the Appeals
Chamber decided that Abdullah al-Senussi’s case was inadmissible before the Court as it
was subject to ongoing domestic proceedings and that Libya was willing and able to carry
out such investigation; also he was considered to be in State custody. On 10 December, the
Pre-Trial Chamber found that Libya had failed to surrender Mr. Qadhafi to the Court, and
referred the matter to the United Nations Security Council.
70.
To date, both Saif al-Islam Qadhafi and Abdullah al-Senussi have been unable to
access legal counsel representing them before the International Criminal Court. In her
briefing to the Security Council on 12 November 2014, the Prosecutor noted that the
“ongoing violence and alleged threats to judges, prosecutors and lawyers do not augur well
for a fair trial”. She further noted that she would assess options, “including whether to
apply for a review of the judge’s decision upholding Libya’s request that the case against
Mr. Al-Senussi be tried in Libya”.
71.
On 25 July 2014, the Prosecutor issued a statement that she “[would] not hesitate to
investigate and prosecute those who commit crimes under the Court’s jurisdiction in Libya,
irrespective of their official status or affiliation.”
6.
Law on Political and Administrative Isolation
72.
The authorities have undertaken limited or no vetting of new members of the armed
forces, law enforcement, judiciary or Judicial Police. In contrast, extensive measures
targeting those affiliated with the Qadhafi regime have been applied. Law No. 13 of 2013
on Political and Administrative Isolation lists a wide range of political, administrative and
other positions under the Qadhafi regime, as well as types of affiliation and conduct, as a
basis for excluding individuals from public life for 10 years. It contains criteria which are
14
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents